CreateDebate


Debate Info

4
1
Endless cycle of madness Chop nose off to spite face
Debate Score:5
Arguments:4
Total Votes:6
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Endless cycle of madness (2)
 
 Chop nose off to spite face (1)

Debate Creator

potatosalad(329) pic



The reality of a Proletariat vs Bourgeoisie cycle

In reality, an overthrow of the Bourgeoisie by the
Proletariat would lead to anarchy, chaos, and mass destruction. It would then just lead to a new Bourgeoisie forming inside of the old Proletariat. Rinse, wash, repeat.

Endless cycle of madness

Side Score: 4
VS.

Chop nose off to spite face

Side Score: 1
No arguments found. Add one!
1 point

In reality, an overthrow of the Bourgeoisie by the

Proletariat would lead to anarchy, chaos, and mass destruction. It would then just lead to a new Bourgeoisie forming inside of the old Proletariat. Rinse, wash, repeat.

This is the textbook authoritarian argument, which was also used to legitimise the enslavement of blacks. Blacks need to be controlled by whites because they are savages who would all kill each other if left to their own devices. It is just as stupid and false now as it was then.

Side: Chop nose off to spite face
Amarel(5140) Disputed
3 points

How do all the nations workers actually decide what to do with means of production?

How do they collectively decide who specifically does what specifically?

How exactly does the people determine what new means of production to create?

If I build my own means of production, must I give it to the nations workers? Who do I give it to?

Side: Endless cycle of madness
Mingiwuwu(1467) Clarified
2 points

"Less how, more Gulag-work slave!"

- Your beloved leader King-Kong Ooooooooooooh

Side: Endless cycle of madness
Bronto(2003) Disputed
1 point

This is the textbook authoritarian argument

It is the textbook common sense arguement. You'd get your revolution and simply replace the monarchs with monarchs that used you like a prostitute to get to their ends.

Side: Endless cycle of madness