CreateDebate


Debate Info

20
7
Titanic Avatar
Debate Score:27
Arguments:19
Total Votes:31
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Titanic (13)
 
 Avatar (6)

Debate Creator

Axmeister(4322) pic



Titanic vs Avatar

After recently watching Titanic I decided to search up some videos of it on Youtube. Soon after I noticed the following comment posted under many of those videos:

"TITANIC IS BETTER THAN AVATAR. THAT IS A FACT. HOWEVER, AVATAR HAS MADE $940 MILLION MORE THAN TITANIC. WE HAVE THE CHANCE TO CHANGE THIS. TITANIC IS BEING RE-RELEASED INTO CINEMAS IN 3D NEXT YEAR TO CELEBRATE THE 100TH ANNIVERSARY OF THE SINKING OF TITANIC. IF EVERYONE GOES TO SEE IT, THEN TITANIC WILL RECLAIM IT'S CORRECT POSITION AS THE MOST SUCCESSFUL FILM OF ALL TIME. TELL ALL OF YOUR FAMILY AND FRIENDS TO GET OUT AND GO TO SEE IT. ALSO, PLEASE SPREAD THIS MESSAGE."

Now I wonder which film does deserve to be the most successful movie of all time: Titanic or Avatar?

Titanic

Side Score: 20
VS.

Avatar

Side Score: 7
3 points

Obviously Titanic! Screw Avatar................! You Losers!!!!!!!! I hate that F Movie! How dare this debate even exists.....?!!!!!

Excuse me for the Rant:-(!

Side: Titanic
1 point

I feel the same way that you do, but the debate is questioning whihc movie has the right to hold the position of best selling movie of all time.

Side: Titanic
2 points

Titanic man.. After all like THE BEST OF THIS ERA! IT's all about LOVE LOVE LOVE LOVE LOVE! I love Titanicc... Whoooooooooooooooo!

Side: Titanic
2 points

Titanic 4 sure!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Avatar was WAY to Liberal!!!!! It was Hollywood's way of saying, "BE A TREE-HUGGER!!!"

Side: Titanic

Lets not forget exploiter.-------------------------------------------------

Side: Titanic

The real highest grossing film adjusted for inflation is Gone with the Wind. Titanic is 6th and Avatar is 14th. Inflation Rate

Side: Titanic
2 points

I'm on the Titanic side. Just because Avatar made more money than Titanic, doesn't mean it was better quality. I like the Titanic because in a sense its history. The Titanic was an actual ship, and alot if the details in the movie were historically correct.

Cameron even took a dive down to the shipwreck for the movie.

Im not saying Avatar was bad ( It was actually pretty good!) I just like the historical sense of the Titanic better.

Side: Titanic
1 point

Titanic has more British People in it, loads of the good people who die are British and it's a better commemeration to a historical event than Avatar.

Side: Titanic
1 point

Titanic The Movie is basically a piece of history! Where as to Avatar, it's a fictional story based on nothing! All that Avatar shows are signs that the people who wrote are living in a fantasy world!

Side: Titanic
Axmeister(4322) Disputed
2 points

This plot to Avatar is ridiculously similar to that of Disney's Pochahantus, which was based on the English colonization of North America and how the Natie Americans where treated.

Side: Titanic
1 point

I bet Titanic made you cry more than Avatar. You could easily connect with Titanic because it was real, almost all its characters were real and the accident was real. Avatar had nothing of that sort. And yes, DiCaprio was not the only reason titanic became the best movie ever.

Side: Titanic
1 point

I agree with your opinion. Titanic is much more interesting than Avatar because Titanic is based on a true story aa route planner and Avatar is just fiction.

Side: Titanic
1 point

I'm surprised Disney hasn't sued the guy yet.

Side: Avatar
1 point

Sorry, but I can't possibly vote in favor of a movie that is essentially "let's watch some people take a boat ride... spoiler to entire world, it hits an iceberg and sinks at the end."

I have enough issues with hollywood telegraphing the endings to stories without dealing with that. Titanic made as much as it did because of all the adolescent girls who were crushing on DiCaprio. The end.

Side: Avatar
Axmeister(4322) Disputed
1 point

"Sorry, but I can't possibly vote in favor of a movie that is essentially "let's watch some people take a boat ride... spoiler to entire world, it hits an iceberg and sinks at the end."

So you'ld rather imagine humanity as a race that will gladly aim for the extinction of other intelligant species if it profits them, than a society of people who would sacrifice their lives to save others.

"I have enough issues with hollywood telegraphing the endings to stories without dealing with that. Titanic made as much as it did because of all the adolescent girls who were crushing on DiCaprio. The end."

And you saying that Avatar wasn't filled with young boys wanting to see some fancy CGI?

Side: Titanic

Determining the "most successful movie of all time" is subjective and can be measured in different ways. Two commonly used metrics are box office revenue and critical acclaim. Rainbow Friends: Chapter 2

Side: Avatar
0 points

Titanic is a wonderful Movie but it lacks the dash that is obvious in Avatar. Avatar was put in with lots of afford. Titanic is Awesome too.

Side: Avatar
0 points

Titanic is wank, although Avatar is also, but to a lesser extent. Big budget movies usually are.

Side: Avatar