CreateDebate


Debate Info

8
5
looks like a vacation was take skin-cancer and racism
Debate Score:13
Arguments:10
Total Votes:13
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 looks like a vacation was take (5)
 
 skin-cancer and racism (5)

Debate Creator

VenusEve(170) pic



To tan or not to tan

1. If you tan you damage your melanin.

You expose yourself to AGING of the epidermis as well.

2. If you tan you are saying your white skin is racially inferior as darker skin is what you are after.

It is not healthy self-esteem either to alter your skin tone: what you were born with whatever that may be is just right or it wouldn't be so.

looks like a vacation was take

Side Score: 8
VS.

skin-cancer and racism

Side Score: 5
2 points

I don't think there is necessarily a racist element to skin tanning. Tanning your skin just means you, personally, think that darker skin makes you look more attractive. You might think that certain people would look better with other skin tones. Even if you think that everyone would look better with tanned skin, that's still just an aesthetic preference that may not be linked to social discrimination.

Another thing to note is that getting a tan doesn't mean you want to look like people from a race that has naturally darker skin. Most white people who get tans aren't trying to turn themselves into Hispanics or Indians or Africans. They're just trying to look like white people who have a tan.

This argument goes the other way too: more than once, I've heard white people lamenting that Asians have a racial inferiority complex and want to become Caucasians, citing the fact that skin-whitening treatments are very popular in Asia. As an Asian who likes pale skin, I have to say that that is simply untrue. Most Asians who use skin whiteners just want to look like Asians with pale skin, because pale skin has long been considered an aspect of beauty, like slimness or lustrous hair. They don't want to look like white people, and suggesting that they do actually comes across as rather patronising.

As to the self-esteem issue... I don't believe that altering your appearance means you lack self-esteem. I think it's quite natural and healthy for people to want to "look their best". Heavy reliance on makeup, clothing, or cosmetic surgery may indicate psychological problems, but it's not a very reliable indicator. In fact, some people with very low self-esteem take the other extreme and simply don't bother to improve their appearance, because they don't think they're capable of creating a good impression on people anyway.

Physical health problems with tanning is certainly a concern, but this is more a matter of practising moderation rather than simply not tanning at all. People do need a certain amount of sunlight to be healthy.

Personally, I wouldn't get a tan, because I don't think it would look good on me. But I don't have a problem with other people getting tans, as long as they take some reasonable safety measures while doing it.

Side: looks like a vacation was take
2 points

I didn't know which side to choose. But, if you wanna tan you should just do it. If you are going to think of what this color might do to your racial feeling you are just thinking Crap. You don't have to think of color ever as a racist ideal.

Side: looks like a vacation was take
1 point

Neither side was worthy of using as a response, but I chose this side. I am of American Indian descent, so I tan easily and stay darker through the winter. I will pull off my shirt to work in the yard or pasture to stay cooler and because I enjoy the sun. There is no better source for vitamin D than the sun. As far as damaging your melanin, melanin acts as a sunscreen and protects the skin from ultraviolet light. Melanin is produced by cells called melanocytes. It provides some protection against skin damage from the sun, and the melanocytes increase their production of melanin in response to sun exposure.

Side: looks like a vacation was take
ENDT91(36) Disputed
1 point

Melanin produced during sun exposure, while stronger than most topical sunblocks, cannot protect from the sun exposure that triggered its production. Those tans that you get in a day is actually just the melanin that is already present in your skin oxidizing. A true tan take 2-3 days to full develop. Even so, it has been shown in dermatology that melanin itself will not protect you from all effects of sun. It is essentially a visible sign of sun damage.

Side: skin-cancer and racism
Merlin13(1258) Disputed
1 point

I'm not disputing the facts that melanin will not fully protect you; I was disputing the claim of it damaging the melanin. I cannot find anything that corroborates that statement. If you know of any, please post a link. I don't mind being proven wrong if there are facts.

Side: looks like a vacation was take

I don't care..............I just want points.................anyway, it's their choice

Side: skin-cancer and racism
Peekaboo(704) Disputed
2 points

Points will come naturally; there's no need to spam debates with pointless posts for them :/

It's not like there's an e-peen contest for high points going on anyway, unless you're trying to beat Joe, which you aren't going to for a very long time.

Side: looks like a vacation was take
1 point

I vote to not tan. Not because of racism or anything, because to create an argument like that regarding the changing of skin color makes the world appear as if things are black and white. First thing, melanin is a pigment. It can't be damaged. Second thing, by saying that the changing of skin color is racist, one could extend that to saying that changing hair color is racist. Melanin contributes to skin, hair, and eye color. If skin color doesn't define who a person is, then how is it racist? I don't even think skin lightening is racist. The ideas behind it may be racist, but not everyone who lightens their skin has those same ideas just as not everybody who tans has the idea that they want to be another race.

Racism aside, I personally do not like to tan on purpose as the damage from the sun has a negative cumulative effect on skin health and has been shown to greatly increase the chances of skin cancer. Melanin production is a sign of stress on your skin. There are other ways to get that sun kissed look without the damage that gets accumulated.

Side: skin-cancer and racism