CreateDebate is a social debate community built around ideas, discussion and democracy.
If this is your first time checking out a debate, here are some quick tips to help get you started:
Arguments with the highest score are displayed first.
Argument replies (both in favor and in opposition) are displayed below the original argument.
To follow along, you may find it helpful to show and hide the replies displayed below each argument.
To vote for an argument, use these icons:
You have the power to cast exactly one vote (either up or down) for each argument.
Once you vote, the icon will become grayed out and the argument's score will change.
Yes, you can change your vote.
Debate scores, side scores and tag scores are automatically calculated by an algorithm that primarily takes argument scores into account.
All scores are updated in real-time.
To learn more about the CreateDebate scoring system, check out the FAQ.
When you are ready to voice your opinion, use the Add Argument button to create an argument.
If you would like to address an existing argument, use the Support and Dispute link within that argument to create a new reply.
The guy who said this level of economic success was impossible. Who can forget that braniac
It's OK Bronto. People criticised Hitler too, despite his impossible economic successes. How ignorant they were to the greatness of your beloved Fuhrer.
I'm sorry to hear that hootie. It must have been very traumatic for you that your leftist hero was ridiculed like that. Taken your prozak today? If not, you'd better grab a handfull because someone said a bad thing about your Socialist, anti-Jewish daddy.
I'm sorry to hear that hootie. It must have been very traumatic for you that your leftist hero was ridiculed like that. Taken your prozak today? If not, you'd better grab a handfull because someone said a bad thing about your Socialist, anti-Jewish daddy.
You're a sopping wet dildo in the ass of a native american buffalo.
It's okay that you are going to ignore Hitler claiming Nazism was liberal. It's also okay that you are going to ignore Goebbels saying Nazism was Communism. Now call your mom down to tuck you in.
It's okay that you are going to ignore Hitler claiming Nazism was liberal.
I am not ignoring what Hitler said. You are ignoring that Hitler was a liar. You sit here all day literally repeating the lies of Adolf Hitler. It's stupid.
Okay. Let's do a test. Hitler said he hated Jews. Lie or truth?
You are objectively wrong Bronto. Hitler was on the far right.
If Hitler lied about having liberal views, then that does not necessarily mean he lied about hating Jews. This guilt-by-association tactic is just another part of your deranged effort to circumvent reality. You reject all sources except Adolf Hitler, and then use Adolf Hitler's lies to attack your enemies with. How are you not a Nazi?
So which of his statements shall I take as true, and which ones should I take as false?
This research has already been done for you by countless historical scholars. It's the same research you keep ignoring because it doesn't match the lies of Adolf Hitler, you idiotic Nazi halfwit.
For example:-
The majority of scholars identify Nazism in both theory and practice as a form of far-right politics.[14] Far-right themes in Nazism include the argument that superior people have a right to dominate other people and purge society of supposed inferior elements.[15] Adolf Hitler and other proponents denied that Nazism was either left-wing or right-wing, instead they officially portrayed Nazism as a syncretic movement
It is explained right there for you in the text that Hitler wanted people to believe he represented liberals so that he could win their vote. But you keep ignoring everything which did not come out of the mouth of Adolf Hitler. Adolf Hitler is the only source you are prepared to believe.
Again. Hitler said he hated Jews. A lie or not a lie? And if not a lie, why would I randomly assume "I'm a socialist" is a lie? Why would I randomly assume that "I'm a Marxist" is a lie"? Why would I randomly assume that "We need to grab the guns" was not Himmler's true desire? Because you, 80 years later say so?
Again. Hitler said he hated Jews. A lie or not a lie?
That is half the story, so I guess it depends on what your definition of a lie is. Hitler claimed he was fighting against Jewish Marxism. Being quite an obvious liar however, you have removed the part about Marxism so you can later go back and accuse the Nazis of being Marxists. Hence, not only are you refusing to believe anybody who is not a Nazi, but you are also twisting the words of the Nazis themselves!! Quite remarkable.
Why would I randomly assume that "We need to grab the guns" was not Himmler's true desire?
You were not asked to "randomly assume" anything. You were provided with direct quotations from academic experts. Your question should be: "Why would I randomly assume the Nazis are telling me the truth, when I am staring at an in-depth analysis of why they are lying?" See:-
The Nazis adopted a new gun law in 1938. According to an analysis by Bernard Harcourt, a professor at Columbia University School of Law, it loosened gun ownership rules in several ways.
It deregulated the buying and selling of rifles, shotguns and ammunition. It made handguns easier to own by allowing anyone with a hunting license to buy, sell or carry one at any time. (You didn’t need to be hunting.) It also extended the permit period from one year to three and gave local officials more discretion in letting people under 18 get a gun.
But that is the opposite of what I am doing, and the definition of what you are doing. Hitler hated Jews because he blamed them for Marxism, but you purposefully omitted that information because it doesn't fit your deranged narrative that Hitler was a Marxist.
You keep typing Bronto, but all that is coming out is a whole lot of stupid.
Hitler hated Jews because he blamed them for Marxism
, but you purposefully omitted that information because it doesn't fit your deranged narrative that Hitler was a Marxist.
Aah. Now we are back to we can believe Hitler. It's like a ping pong ball, eh nom? Great. Let's continue.
He demonized Jews with anything he could. He also claimed Marxism was Socialism too far. He then praised socialism, which isn't quite Marxism. He also allied with Bolsheviks, who praised Marx, and Mussolini, who praised Marx.
You keep typing Bronto, but all that is coming out is a whole lot of stupid.
Ad hominem, per desperation. Avoiding Mussolini like the plague, eh Nom?
No, now we are back with Hitler's stated views about Marxism being consistent with the several million Marxists he had executed and the fact that he tried to invade Russia.
Great. Let's continue.
Let's not. Your deranged narrative is self-contradictory and stupid.
He demonized Jews with anything he could
Right. So now we are back to we can believe Hitler?
Fuck off Bronto. You're literally a Nazi and it's that simple.
No, now we are back with Hitler's stated views about Marxism being consistent with the several million Marxists he had executed and the fact that he tried to invade Russia.
He also allied with Russia previously and with Mussolini, who idolized Marx.
Great. Let's continue.
Let's not. Your deranged narrative is self-contradictory and stupid.
You've avoided most of my points intentionally because you have no way of rebuttling. Very telling.
He demonized Jews with anything he could
Right. So now we are back to we can believe Hitler?
Fuck off Bronto. You're literally a Nazi and it's that simple.
No, now we are back with Hitler's stated views about Marxism being consistent with the several million Marxists he had executed and the fact that he tried to invade Russia.
Stalin was a Marxist. He killed millions of Marxists. He also allied with Hitler at one point. Not much help for you there.
No. It's exactly what you are doing. You are trying to detach Hitler's fondness of some Marxist ideas and fondness of Socialism from Marxism as a whole.
It's the same as a person who dislikes Christianity's overall message, but nevertheless, still practices Christian virtues. It's not a repudiation of Christian values but of the message as a collective.
1. Who are Trump's minions? 2. Do all of his "minions" love him? 3. The Left loves and will continue to love anyone who signals the virtues they hold dear. Bonus points are awarded for chanting with the crowd. "Orange Man Bad" (feel free to replace "orange man" with any right-wing conservative flavor of the week)
YES! Our families, who now have a CHANCE (again) to save their SS and Medicare/Medicaid, keep the VERY important "pre-existing conditions" clause AND work to save our environment.
Of course we also have time, now, for a large number of "minions" to come back to reality and see the damage being done to our democracy. Maybe they'd even save the GOP that has gone down in flames. That would be nice. We NEED two parties that can work together!
These "minions" that want "One nation, under Trump", SHOULD realize that more than half the country doesn't want what they are selling …. and THAT half of the country has rights also! We won't make America great again by going "nationalist" politically.
I don't know what "group" you are referring to that supports open borders. Certainly NOT the DNC. I don't know who you are referring to that "burns the flag" certainly NOT any legitimate Democratic group. I don't know who you are referring to that "kneels in protest to the flag". There may be some, but, it's NOT the NFL players, THEY are kneeling to protest unfair and unequal treatment by people who are supposed to PROTECT AND SERVE! THAT is a legitimate, PEACEFUL, 1st Amendment protest and NOT disrespectful to the flag!
I get called a Nazi every day, it seems. I hate Nazis, I SAW, in real time, the things they did … you know, those things conspiracy theorists say "didn't happen"! I will say that, a person who calls themselves a "Nationalist" (which is what Nazis were/are), is a dangerous person to democracy! You are apparently a victim of the REAL "fake news". "DUPE".
YES! Our families, who now have a CHANCE (again) to save their SS and Medicare/Medicaid, keep the VERY important "pre-existing conditions" clause AND work to save our environment.
Of course we also have time, now, for a large number of "minions" to come back to reality and see the damage being done to our democracy. Maybe they'd even save the GOP that has gone down in flames. That would be nice. We NEED two parties that can work together!
These "minions" that want "One nation, under Trump", SHOULD realize that more than half the country doesn't want what they are selling …. and THAT half of the country has rights also! We won't make America great again by going "nationalist" politically.
GRANDPAW your 81 years old and your SS has been threatened !!! You PARROTS got nothing but the Slop you consume from Drive By Media !!!!!!!!!!!!
