CreateDebate


Debate Info

19
79
Twilight Harry Potter
Debate Score:98
Arguments:59
Total Votes:133
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Twilight (18)
 
 Harry Potter (41)

Debate Creator

twihard4ever(1) pic



Twilight vs Harry Potter

Twilight is the best romantic drama with the vampires and werewolves.Where would we go wrong,twilight has the evil villans like harry potter.But the villans in twilight are better they can acually put better emotions on the audiance.

But in harry potters movie there is no real villans in the movie.All there is are a couple of weird lokkin dudes dressed in black and the way to kill people is to say weird sounding words,a flash of lights come on and the persons dead.Not to forget on harry potter robert pattinson who plays edward cullen is sedrick diggery on harry potter.

Twilight

Side Score: 19
VS.

Harry Potter

Side Score: 79
0 points

i thinnk twilight is better but that just my choice.

the books and the movies are soooo good.

cant wait for next movie:)

Side: Twilight
-1 points

Twilight in the world is the best thing that ever happend to all of us.If this was real,we would know how to spot them out,and i said IF.

Side: Twilight
DaaeDove(1) Disputed
2 points

"Twilight in the world is the best thing that ever happened to all of us." -Okay. Well then. WHAT THE HECK DOES THAT MEAN? I'm going to assume you meant to say "Twilight is the best thing to ever happen to the world".

First off - WHY? You give absolutly NO explanation as to WHY Twilight is so amazing. Why not explaning your statement a little bit more than this?

It makes no sense!

Not to mention, Twilight is probably one of the worst things to happen to girls in our generation, since it promotes abusive relationships to an extreme.

Side: Harry Potter
3 points

Harry Potter for sure. With one flick of his wrist he could lay out Edward and his posse.

Side: Harry Potter
jesschen(8) Banned
2 points

I like both. But I have to say Harry Potter is a lot better. Twilight is all about romance, but Harry Potter is more exciting. Harry Potter is better.

Side: Harry Potter
2 points

The plot is better in Harry Potter and has much better character development than I have seen in Twilight. I am basing my opinions here on the books, but even with the movies, Harry Potter just seems more developed and intellectual, like there is actual mystery and palatable emotions that you receive from the actors. There are also stronger female characters in Harry Potter compared to Twilight; Bella just seems way too apathetic and so weak as a lead character in the first place aka the feminist's worst nightmare.

And yes, read all of the books for each sides to make this statement more plausible. lol

Side: Harry Potter
2 points

Twilight is like Underworld, except not sexy (no Kate Beckinsale), Not cool (No Viktor), not entertaining in any way (No meaningful violence) and completely lacking in all other redeeming qualities. Whereas Underworld gave us a violent, bloody war between vampires and werewolves, Twilight gives us teenage angst, Poor acting, Bad (absent?) plot, and some paranormal activity thrown in, in a vain attempt to separate itself from conventional teen movies. God, it's awful.

Harry Potter, while low in my regard, is at least above this.

Side: Harry Potter
twihard4ever(1) Disputed
0 points

Oh really did you watch eclipse.The battle in the feild is sure vilonce.Heart shocking to some girls when Jacob got squeezed by a newborn trying to save leah.The paranormal activity is the only way bella can see edward with a buckets load of adrenaline.Not only proving the Fast movement in this movie is extrordinary the angst gets our tweenage pumping more then teenage.But how can you not forget Edward who is Really Robert Pattinson also in harry potter who think he has poor acting.In the first movie he had to save bella from the venom going through her body he had to therefor almost break the tready aginst the werewolves.And the sexyness in the movie is the way bella and edward did the makeout in eclipse.Well you be in this argument if you don't specificly know what is going on in each and every movie.I read and watched and reapeted each and every movie and book in each series(except deathly hallows in movie and breaking dawn)but i am telling you in know every single thing in each book and movie.So HA!!!

Side: Twilight
EnigmaticMan(1844) Disputed Banned
3 points

The battle in the feild is sure vilonce.

For pussies.

Heart shocking to some girls when Jacob got squeezed by a newborn trying to save leah.

Squeezed? Dear God, no!

The paranormal activity is the only way bella can see edward with a buckets load of adrenaline.Not only proving the Fast movement in this movie is extrordinary the angst gets our tweenage pumping more then teenage.

At this point, I have no idea what you are attempting to say.

But how can you not forget Edward who is Really Robert Pattinson also in harry potter who think he has poor acting.

I did not say I liked Harry Potter. I said that it was better than Twilight.

In the first movie he had to save bella from the venom going through her body he had to therefor almost break the tready aginst the werewolves.

A pathetic, simplistic representation of diplomacy.

And the sexyness in the movie is the way bella and edward did the makeout in eclipse.

Good Lord! They kissed? All Kate Beckinsale did in Underworld II was have sex!

Well you be in this argument if you don't specificly know what is going on in each and every movie.I read and watched and reapeted each and every movie and book in each series(except deathly hallows in movie and breaking dawn)but i am telling you in know every single thing in each book and movie.So HA!!!

At least you can occupy your pathetically small brain.

Side: Harry Potter
2 points

But in harry potters movie there is no real villans in the movie.All there is are a couple of weird lokkin dudes dressed in black and the way to kill people is to say weird sounding words,a flash of lights come on and the persons dead.Not to forget on harry potter robert pattinson who plays edward cullen is sedrick diggery on harry potter.

So you can't tell who the villains are? Lol.

So what does Robert Pattinson holding a role in a Harry Potter movie have to do with anything?

Side: Harry Potter
2 points

This debate shouldn't even exist, Harry Potter obviously owns Twilight.

Side: Harry Potter
2 points

The Harry Potter Series has captivated men & women, children & adults...and continues to do so. The Twilight Saga hasn't. Simply put, there's no contest between the two.

Side: Harry Potter
2 points

I have to agree...I've read every Potter book but never bothered to read or see anything of the Twilight series.

Side: Harry Potter
2 points

You probably wouldn't like them, they are more about romance and teenage angst than fantasy. If you like Fantasy you should read Raymond Feist's Magician:Apprentice and/or Stephen Lawhead's The Dragon King Trilogy.

Side: Harry Potter
1 point

Ha, Twilight fails. Clearly, you've never read the Harry Potter books, or else you'd realize you were wrong.

Side: Harry Potter
twihard4ever(1) Disputed
0 points

No i clearly watched all the movies(except deathly hallows)and read every book there is known to man of the harry potter collection.

Side: Twilight
1 point

harry potter is a masterpiece of the millennium....nothing better than that ever written..plotted..!!! twilight is the same boring romantic story about a couple which can never possibly exist in real...only a li'l innovative by introducing vampires and 'so called' werewolves...!! whereas harry potter is one of it's kind...a really optimistic story...wid all the showcase...action...thrill...suspense... givin d ever lasting good v/s evil a new height...!!! it includes a piece of story from every genre...nd for every age grp..!!!

Side: Harry Potter

it is way better!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Side: Harry Potter

twilight sucked when Edward sparkled it just made the movie suck :) Harry potter was born awesome

Side: Harry Potter
1 point

This is extremely obvious. The female characters in Harry Potter don't fall apart the second a male character ignores them. They join Dumbledore's Army or search for Horcruxes. Bella can't navigate her driveway without tripping over her own two feet. Friendship and loyalty is an important part of Harry Potter. Harry, Ron, Hermione, Neville, Luna, etc. are there for one another even when their lives are on the line. Even though Luna seems to be rather odd when they all first meet her, they still become her friend and include her. When Bella first starts at her new school, she's quick to judge the people who take an interest in her, rather than being grateful for their friendship. She seems to think she's above them. Sadly, a few of the guys she meets automatically see her as a piece of meat, rather than a potential friend. In Harry Potter, Ron and Harry don't develop a crush on Hermione from the start simply because she's a girl.

Side: Harry Potter
1 point

SHUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUT UP TWILIGHT FANS

Side: Harry Potter
1 point

Harry Potter is SO much more interesting, i have to agree. My cousin showed me part of Twillight- I fell asleep in the first 15 minutes! HARRY POTTER IS AWESOME!

Side: Harry Potter
0 points

I liked the Twilight books, but the movies are terrible, and neither can even come close to comparing to the greatness that is Harry Potter.

Side: Harry Potter
0 points

twilight is good and impressive, but Harry Potter is far more interesting, exciting ,entertaining then Twilight. J.K Rowling's work is outstanding. I am happy to be attached to Harry Potter series.

Side: Harry Potter