CreateDebate


Debate Info

1
4
Killing 'helpless' population Its absurd, immoral and crazy
Debate Score:5
Arguments:3
Total Votes:5
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Killing 'helpless' population (1)
 
 Its absurd, immoral and crazy (2)

Debate Creator

Thought0ut(8) pic



What do you think about killing every 'poor' person on the planet? Let me explain:...

Crazy right?

The world has spent a lot of money on keeping large poor populations alive in Asia and Africa especially, which has its downside. If we were to simply..get rid of everyone who needs food and shelter and maybe education, we would be 'better off' in some ways enough that'll help us focus on a lot of other issues and help us grow since we are not using up money on helping other, of course there is the moral issue, this would be horrible no doubt. But think about the possibilities that could arise from this. I'm saying i would take this decision, i have thought of its absurd and egotistical gravity.

I've been living in south america for awhile, I'm losing my english, don't point out the spelling/grammar mistakes. 

Killing 'helpless' population

Side Score: 1
VS.

Its absurd, immoral and crazy

Side Score: 4
No arguments found. Add one!
3 points

Now that's genocide on the poor class of society. If you kill them, you take their right of living life. I think money that is given is not allocated well at all. I don't have knowledge on how it is allocated but I sure know however it is, it is not working at all. I just say its wrong and its not the way to solve a problem.

Side: Its absurd, immoral and crazy
1 point

yes i think it is wrong. In all actuality your saying we are all poor because nobody is really rich because somebody is always going to have more money than somebody else. It is a proven fact. This is a crazy idea and i don't think this is any kind of argument. Considering people went through more stuff than anyone can imagine, and i am positively sure you can't even imagine. everybody deserves to live whether your poor rich or somewhat...

Side: Its absurd, immoral and crazy
CapeOtter(1) Disputed
1 point

That is crazy :) The only thing that makes someone "rich" is that they are being compared to the "poor" ! Without "poor" there cannot be "rich". The fact is, that the poor masses support the few "rich". It's like a pyramid, with a wide base of poor supporting the rich. Also, consider that, during the lifespan of many people, the make and lose fortunes. Now, what happens if you go on a killing spree at a point when someone experiences a hiccup in their financial journey? I suggest you think of something else with which to occupy your thoughts :)

Side: Killing 'helpless' population