CreateDebate


Debate Info

9
4
He's okay, I guess. He's despicable.
Debate Score:13
Arguments:7
Total Votes:15
Ended:11/27/09
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 He's okay, I guess. (5)
 
 He's despicable. (2)

Debate Creator

MKIced(2511) pic



This debate has ended. You can no longer add arguments or vote in this debate.

What do you think of Brett Favre?

Okay, even if you don't follow sports, this doesn't have much to do with sports, but more to do with character.  I don't like football too much, but Brett Favre has been in the news a lot recently.  Favre was on the Packers for a long time.  Before last season, he retired from the NFL.  Shortly thereafter, he came out of retirement (in 2 weeks or something) and signed on with the Jets.  After a season with the Jets, he retired yet again (which is the case right now).  But he is currently in the process of signing on with the Vikings!  He retired twice and came out of it once, officially, and might come out of retirement again!  It seems like he is just using retirement as a way to get off of a team...

He's okay, I guess.

Side Score: 9
Winning Side!
VS.

He's despicable.

Side Score: 4
3 points

If the man can still play and theres a team that wants to gamble on him...then why not? More power to him.

Side: He's okay, I guess.
2 points

Brett Favre, regardless of his actions in the past few years, is one of the greatest quarterbacks of all time.

Side: Great QB
2 points

Before this season, I didn't like him. But I think he's done a great job with the Vikes. He hasn't exactly been quiet, but he has done a great job of leading Minnesota.

Side: He's okay, I guess.
1 point

What happened, Brett? You can't make up your old mind any more?

Farve is one of my favorite players, but all of this flip flopping between retirments is crazy. All that he is doing is screwing up his legacy, so he's okay, I guess.

Side: He's okay, I guess.
1 point

Brett Favre is one of the best QB to ever play the game! He played for the Packers for 17years and when Randy Moss was a Free Agent Brett told Ted Thompson that we should pick up Moss. Ted said no but i think he said no cause it wasnt his idea! Ever since then Brett and Ted didnt like eachother very much. So Ted realsed Favre and was offering to pay him 21million not to play! Favre loved the game so much that he signed with the Jets and went 9-7! ( Aaron Rodgers went 6-10!) Aaron is not a leader like Favre, and thats why Favre is 7-1 with the vikings. While Aaron is 4-3 so far.(And all of those wins for the packers are against simple teams like the Lions, Browns, Bears, Benglas.) While Favre's wins are against farley hard teams. Yea Aaron might have beter states but its because its all against really simple teams. Well email me at [email protected] i want to hear your comment about Favre.

Side: Great QB
3 points

Well if you listen to John Madden you might think that Brett is an angel sent from heaven to play football.

Personally hes an old man that can't make it into the hall of fame for most yards after being a starting quarter back for longer than any other QB in the games history.

QUIT BRETT YOUR FREAKIN' 70 YEARS OLD!

Side: He's despicable.
1 point

He never was a great player. Just a good player in an outstanding system and I am a life long Packer fan!

Hell I could have won a Super Bowl with that team!

I will give him this...he is as tough as nails!

Side: He's despicable.