CreateDebate


Debate Info

Debate Score:22
Arguments:19
Total Votes:24
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
  (18)

Debate Creator

GuitaristDog(2548) pic



What is government?

Excerpt from Frédéric Bastiat's essay: The State

 

5.1

I wish that someone would offer a prize, not of five hundred francs, but of a million, with crosses, crowns, and ribbons, to whoever would give a good, simple, and intelligible definition of this term: the state.

5.2

What an immense service he would render to society!

5.3

The state! What is it? Where is it? What does it do? What should it do?

5.4

All that we know about it is that it is a mysterious personage, and certainly the most solicited, the most tormented, the busiest, the most advised, the most blamed, the most invoked, and the most provoked in the world.


Add New Argument

Just bought the Bastiat's Complete Collection from the Mises store. Plan on reading sometime this year. Read The Law previously.

Government is an abusive and obtrusive entity with monopolistic powers that subjects unnecessary coercion onto free individuals through many different forms where any economic or political policy benefits the few at the expense of the many with benevolent intentions.

2 points

Government is a monopoly on the initiation of force, also known as central planning. It is representative of the political paradox: an entity designed to prevent predation but possessing the ability to be the most predatory thing in the world.

Government is a contradiction, it is supposed to prevent theft and violence, but has killed and stolen more than any other entity.

True, when comparing those killed by government means to private means, it is not even close. Hundreds of millions were killed by government. More than a hundred million only by two men, Stalin and Mao.

1 point

It's the natural evolution of any social animal; no different than tribes or family units, just more complex.

1 point

How is government the natural evolution of any social animal? As for as I can tell, humans are the only animal with government.

How is being oppressed an natural evolution? Tens of billions have been oppressed by the force of government.

iamdavidh(4856) Disputed
1 point

Government is not inherently oppression any more than a tribal leader or a father may be oppressive. I'd argue the formation of governments governed by people in large part eliminates the historical oppression of authority figures who derive their power from strength and cruelty instead of from a popular vote.

You think you are oppressed because anti-government is like a religion for you. You are not though. You are less oppressed than any caveman ever was. That is reality.

1 point

It is the natural evolution of animals to go say that killing and theft are bad, but then have a leader who is allowed to steal and kill?

Social animals can have social and economic interactions just fine outside of a state run society. Oppression is not natural.

iamdavidh(4856) Disputed
1 point

You and prayerfails read the same fallacious playbook. It's really odd how unoriginal you two can be at times. As I said to him:

Government is not inherently oppression any more than a tribal leader or a father may be oppressive. I'd argue the formation of governments governed by people in large part eliminates the historical oppression of authority figures who derive their power from strength and cruelty instead of from a popular vote.

You think you are oppressed because anti-government is like a religion for you. You are not though. You are less oppressed than any caveman ever was. That is reality.

1 point

To me, the government is a set hierarchy which is used to control the citizens of a nation. To make decisions on the countries welfare, to look after its people, and to, as I stated, control them. Simply because thought it may not be completely true anymore, this is what a government should be. Even if the republicans say otherwise :)