CreateDebate


Debate Info

5
3
Happiness Safety
Debate Score:8
Arguments:10
Total Votes:8
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Happiness (5)
 
 Safety (2)

Debate Creator

DrawFour(2662) pic



What is more important? Happiness or safety.

Happiness

Side Score: 5
VS.

Safety

Side Score: 3
1 point

Why be safe if it doesn't serve the purpose of making one happy?

Side: Happiness
DrawFour(2662) Clarified
1 point

The idea that this debate was created from, but not limited to, was this example.

What if your daughter was happy dating a criminal who put her in dangerous situations. At that point would you care more for her happiness or her safety?

Side: Happiness
1 point

This is possibly nothing more than a non-answer, but I don't really think that anyone would be happy in a such a situation. My daugther would probably desire his company and so on, but desire isn't happiness. So my initial suspicion would be that she wasn't happy with the relationship. Therefore I would probably ask her some harsh questions that would make her think more clearly.

I don't believe you can be truly happy if you have a strong underlying sense of fear. So turned out that she indeed was happy, then I would question whether the criminal really was so dangerous.

I think safety is important, but safety derives its importance from the fact that it's essential for happiness. I think this is why we recognize things like compulsive cleanliness as something bad. So to actually answer your question, I would care for her safety exactly because I care for her happiness. If I sensed an eminent threat I might step in and do something without her consent (like make her break up), but how much I would allow myself to interfere would largely be a function of how much I knew about the relationsship.

Side: Happiness
1 point

Happiness is the basic driving force of humanity. Surely it is better to know happiness for a short amount of time than to be secluded from it by an almost selfish desire for safety. Nothing would really change if everyone preferred safety over happiness, there would be no risk and no pay-off, no freedom to truly do what you want. Both come with a price but only happiness makes that price worth it or at least worth the try.

Side: Happiness

Happiness is more important because happiness creates well-being and a happy person learns to laugh a lot that makes he or she forget about unsafe conditions.

Side: Happiness
2 points

without being safe, you will have a possibility of dying soon. What's the point of happiness, that will soon be gone.

Side: Safety
DrawFour(2662) Clarified
1 point

You said "What's the point of happiness that will be gone soon?", but a similar question can be asked "what's the point of having a long life, if it's not enjoyable?"

Side: Happiness
Kite626(714) Clarified
1 point

But not everyone will obtain that happiness .

Side: Happiness
Stickers(1037) Disputed
1 point

If you die soon, then you've probably had less net experiences of happiness, in which case happiness would not be met. So there is generally safety where there is happiness, but not necessarily happiness where there is safety.

Side: Happiness

Happiness is overrated. The feeling which makes you smile or feel just delighted. I would choose to stay safe, with closed down blinds, turn on some music and enjoy with my achievements so far. Because that's what most live for, most people have dreams and fantasies and desires. A desire to be happy is common. But what could make someone more happier than knowing that his loved ones are safe. And everything what he/she has. Happiness is overrated!

Side: Safety