CreateDebate


Debate Info

11
34
They HATE Jews Gotta set the record straight
Debate Score:45
Arguments:10
Total Votes:46
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 They HATE Jews (7)
 
 Gotta set the record straight (10)

Debate Creator

excon(15694) pic



What is the OBSESSION with DENYING my Jewishness?? Truly.. I don't get it.

Hello:

This is NEW for me..  I've been badmouthed for BEING a Jew, but NEVER for NOT being one.  Something is screwy in this debate, and I don't know what it is..  Clearly, I have a stake because, well, it's about ME..  But, for the life of me, I cannot SEE what stake these people have in DENYING that I'm a Jew..  And, then denying it again, and again and even again, to the point of OBSESSION..

Does a Jewish RACE frighten them?  If I'm really a Jew, will the earth shake?  Will somebody's life change?  Something important is surly gonna happen or these deniers wouldn't be so OBSESSED, and they clearly are.. In fact, they are SO obsessed  they BELIEVE because the DNA lab that did my test is owned by a Jew, of course, he's gonna lie and cheat to make me appear Jewish..   The REASON why he'd do that has NEVER been revealed..

So, again, I apologize to the membership for this crazy stuff..  But, I am NOT the one who perpetuates it..  Yes, I COULD let it go.  But, in honor of the 6,000,000 Jews who were murdered by haters, I VOWED to NEVER stand silent in the face of antisemitism..  And, I won't.

excon

They HATE Jews

Side Score: 11
VS.

Gotta set the record straight

Side Score: 34
1 point

Israelis are religious Jews and hence you are conflating the opinion of religious Jews with science.

Hello hater:

Let's be clear about what you're saying.. Religious Jews will set up a pseudo DNA company in order to LIE and CHEAT, for no other reason than they're religious Jews..

And, you say you don't HATE Jews...

DUDE!

excon

Side: They HATE Jews

What is the OBSESSION with DENYING my Jewishness?? Truly.. I don't get it.

Everyone hates the Jews Con. Except for right wing Christians...

Side: Gotta set the record straight
excon(15694) Disputed
1 point

everyone hates Jews con

Hello bront,

Hate I understand. Being obsessed with denying I’m a Jew, I don’t.

excon

Side: They HATE Jews
5 points

Hate I understand.

Well yeah. Just watch CNN or MSNBC for about 30 minutes. Everything psychology tells you to avoid for good mental health hsppens there nonstop...

Side: Gotta set the record straight
5 points

Being obsessed with denying I’m a Jew, I don’t.

Preaching to the choir con. Do like me. Call the guy a mindless dick with ears, tell him to go get a job and leave mommy's basement, and then tell him what I tell him...

https://i1.wp.com/www.bestpranksbymail.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/middle-finger-3.jpg?fit=2000,1500&ssl=1

Side: Gotta set the record straight
2 points

Every word you write drips with intellectual dishonesty. It is not up to others to "deny" completely unsupported claims which you or anybody else makes. The science says that there are no genetic markers for Jewishness, which is -- funnily enough -- also what reason says, given that Judaism is a monotheistic religion, not a biological race.

You are not Jewish, it has been proven that you are not Jewish, but since you are such a mentally unstable idiot you believe that screaming "DNA" and "JEW HATER" in the faces of anybody who challenges your intellectually redundant claims, classifies as some form of validation.

The "obsession" you describe is with finding out why you are denying the scientific evidence which is being repeatedly linked for you illustrating that you are not Jewish. For example:-

Genetic markers cannot determine Jewish descent

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4301023/

Female ancestors of most modern Ashkenazi Jews converted to Judaism in the north Mediterranean around 2,000 years ago and later in west and central Europe

https://www.the-scientist.com/daily-news/genetic-roots-of-the-ashkenazi-jews-38580

There is absolutely ZERO genetic relationship between you and Judaism, and the solitary argument you have to the contrary is that you paid a private Israeli ancestry website to conduct what they claimed to be a DNA test. Since this private Israeli business used the words "Ashkenazi Jew" to describe your DNA (hence disqualifying themselves as scientists in the first place) you have decided to take their erroneous use of semantics quite literally, and have simply ignored the scientific explanation of why they made this error:-

Obviously, what kept Jews identity were their language, culture, tradition and religion. Thus, whatever their biological hereditary kinships, both the trans-generational vertical, and intra-generation horizontal relationships are secondary consequences. However, the increasing reliance on scientific reductionism in biological thinking of the last two centuries eventually culminated in turning the evidence of DNA sequences into the essence of the characterization of Jewishness rather than its consequence. Still, in spite of repeated efforts, there is no agreed upon criterion to identify Jews, and samples examined for the distribution of biological or molecular markers all depend on the preconceived biases of the investigators

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4301023/

Oh, well let's see now. A group of Israeli Jewish capitalists having "preconceived biases" about Judaism? Never. Outrageous.

Side: Gotta set the record straight
excon(15694) Disputed
1 point

Hello hater:

Yeah, yeah, yeah.. I've heard it before..

But, what I wanna know is WHY you're SOOOO obsessed with it.. There's something going on over there.. For SOME reason, you MUST, to point of OBSESSION, DENY that I'm Jewish... If it's NOT hate, I cannot imagine what it is..

Is it FEAR? What else could it be? Putting me in my place can't be it.. Of course, you won't say.. Maybe one of our other subscribers knows WHY..

excon

Side: They HATE Jews
5 points

But, what I wanna know is WHY you're SOOOO obsessed with it.. There's something going on over there.. For SOME reason, you MUST, to point of OBSESSION, DENY that I'm Jewish... If it's NOT hate, I cannot imagine what it is..

Is it FEAR? What else could it be? Putting me in my place can't be it.. Of course, you won't say.. Maybe one of our other subscribers knows WHY..

You called? Yes, Nom hates Jews. Why? A man with a square stache, claiming to be a National Socialist indoctrinated him...

Side: Gotta set the record straight
1 point

Truly.. I don't get it.

Use Viagra and you just might some time.

Side: Gotta set the record straight
1 point

LMAO

Side: Gotta set the record straight