CreateDebate


Debate Info

17
38
Christianity Scientology
Debate Score:55
Arguments:38
Total Votes:55
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Christianity (14)
 
 Scientology (21)

Debate Creator

Hellno(17753) pic



Which Religion is the Most Stupidest And Stuff?

Christianity

Side Score: 17
VS.

Scientology

Side Score: 38
3 points

As far as I know Scientology doesn't contradict itself in it's own writings, so that would make it more illogical to be a Christian, where contradiction is rampant.

Side: Christianity
lolzors93(3225) Disputed
2 points

The Bible has no contradictions in it.

Side: Scientology
Stryker(849) Disputed
2 points

Was Jesus silent during his trial before Pilate?

Yes: Matthew 27:12-14, Mark 15:3-5

No: John 18:33-38

This is just one of the hundreds of contradictions found in the Bible.

Side: Christianity
1 point

Agreed. Well played sir... well played.

Side: Christianity
1 point

Noah and the Ark... Bullshit, two animals of every species on Earth? Bwhahaha!

Side: Christianity
lolzors93(3225) Disputed
1 point

Not of every species; two of every kind.

Side: Scientology
GuitarGuy(6096) Disputed
1 point

Or in other words; two of every kind of animal... which he already said.

Side: Christianity
Cartman(18192) Disputed
1 point

So he only brought 2 dogs, and 2 cats? How did we get all of the different variety of cats and dogs?

Side: Christianity
1 point

True... but almost everything beats two of a kind. :D

Side: Scientology
1 point

I believe the writing said two of every kind. Not necessarily two of every species.

Kind could refer to genus, family, possible even order.

Taking two of every non-aquatic genus is still likely bullshit.

Family, perhaps. That's still a LOT but its at least been narrowed down to something remotely feasible. Breeding pairs of each family could conceivably have diversified into the many genera and species we see today.

Order would certainly be doable in terms of quantity, but I don't believe evolution could account for the diversity we see today if only 2 representatives of each order were brought.

I suppose it all depends on what 'kind' we're talking about. Especially considering that even within the same species there are different 'kinds' Look at the many different breeds of canis lupus familiaris! Look at the various races of homo sapiens!

The real question for this passage is "How is 'kind' defined?"

Side: Scientology
1 point

I wouldn't say Christianity is stupid, because everyone can believe in what they want to, but all I'm here to say is that it is really confusing. 1. Now, let's say that God really created the earth and all. If this happened, where in there did the dinosaurs evolve? After all God created the species that live on this planet now, and in science, they evolved from dinosaurs. But the Bible doesn't say anything about that, does it? 2. Adam and Eve: They're portrayed as homo sapiens sapiens, but the homo sapiens sapiens evolved from the homo sapiens neanderthalensis. The bible doesn't say anything about that either. Still, I respect whatever you want to believe in, because it's your own personal choice, but personally I believe more in science than christianity.

Side: Christianity
3 points

Zeno? Or whatever the fuck his name is...? Jesus fucking Christ!

Side: Scientology
3 points

I actually bought into Christianity growing up and I even thought Scientology was stupid then. Now I think they're both ridiculous but Scientology is still tough to beat.

Side: Scientology
2 points

Hold up son! What? Are you a Sociologist?

Side: Scientology
2 points

I'm a 'Merican... from 'Merica!

Side: Scientology
3 points

Maybe I'm just used to the crazy of Christianity, but Scientology seems far more out there.

Side: Scientology

I like to think that i am a tolerant person, but Scientology is one of the very few belief system that i dislike with a passion. I honestly do not even consider it to be a religion. I see it as a dangerous cult.

Side: Scientology
2 points

It's the most idiotic religion/cult that I've ever heard of.

Side: Scientology