CreateDebate


Debate Info

Debate Score:9
Arguments:16
Total Votes:10
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Which haplogroups qualify as "white"? (9)

Debate Creator

JustIgnoreMe(4316) pic



Which haplogroups qualify as "white"?

Which haplogroups qualify as "white"?
Add New Argument
1 point

That's correct, keep the RAY-CIST flag flying.

You've found a new word and you come on here, where most people, well me at least, never heard of the term and then do a bit of showboating by asking a ridiculous racist orientated question which could be answered accurately and comprehensively by a number of sites specializing in human genetics.

If you really want a scientific answer to your question go and research it on the likes of Wikipedia.

JustIgnoreMe(4316) Clarified
1 point

"You've found a new word"

I was asking the same question over three years ago:

"I've always wanted to ask a white supremacist which haplogroups they think qualify as 'white'?"

https://www.createdebate.com/browse/waterfall/JustIgnoreMe/2400/96

And created a related debate last year:

Should racial supremacists groups use blood tests for admission?

And its point is to move the discussion past 'black' and 'white' in two main ways:

1) To create divisions among white supremacists around which groups qualify - Italians? Greeks? Turks? Latinos? Russians? Scandinavians? etc. etc.

2) I assume many of them don't know much about it either, so the act of trying to decide teaches them about the science and demonstrates how their own ancestry is connected to Africa, etc.

"a scientific answer to your question"

There is no scientific answer to my question. Race is a biproduct of the human tendency to categorize things into groups, which has positive and negative manifestations.

Miocene(432) Disputed
1 point

Okay, off you go on your continuing journey to discover the answer to a question for which there is no scientific answer.

Hey, good luck with that, but please ''include me out'' of your crusade.

BurritoLunch(4219) Clarified
0 points

I was asking the same question over three years ago

This is the second time I've had to explain to you that you can edit your own posts on this website at any time provided they haven't been voted on at the time of editing. You are another just like Bronto, who drops misleading links, uses stacked language and omits anything which compromises your ideological narrative.

0 points

There is no scientific answer to my question. Race is a biproduct of the human tendency to categorize things into groups

Translation: I read an article on the internet and now I think I'm an expert on race.