CreateDebate


Debate Info

16
30
High Taxes Low Taxes
Debate Score:46
Arguments:45
Total Votes:46
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 High Taxes (16)
 
 Low Taxes (28)

Debate Creator

AbbyNestor(1028) pic



Which is better for the economy? High or low taxes?

Which kind of tax would benefit the economy? For example if everybody paid 60 percent or something crazy or like a 5-9% tax rate. Which would be more beneficial?

High Taxes

Side Score: 16
VS.

Low Taxes

Side Score: 30

I think a higher tax is pretty good. More public support and more benefits for people.

Side: High Taxes
AbbyNestor(1028) Disputed
2 points

Oh poor Lizzie. Medicaid and Medicare is why our economy is in the pits. Higher levels of taxation won't do the trick. People need more money in their pockets.

Side: Low Taxes
1 point

Yeah, pretty much. It's actually much healthier for the economy if people are able to inject their funds directly into it instead of the government. They'd just waste it on the next trillion dollar war project anyway.

Side: Low Taxes
1 point

Hmm. I see. Wont most people save it though? The government could repair more roads or make internal improvment on whatever it wanted.

Side: High Taxes
1 point

High taxes are better for the economy. However, they are not good for society. Government does spread money around. It buys things... even debt oddly enough. Saving money is not good for the economy.

Side: High Taxes
jamieo2810(11) Disputed
1 point

High taxes are only better for the economy if those taxes are being spent by the government on projects that are likely to generate further wealth or jobs. When the government is exercising austerity they are taking money out of the circular flow of income. With less money in the economy, economic growth is slowed. When growth is slowed fewer jobs are created less consumer spending occurs, business revenues don't reach their full potential and it creates a vicious cycle, that can seriously harm the economy.

Side: Low Taxes

We have high taxes where I live .. like the one's you said. 60% for some, higher for millionaires.

We have free healthcare and education. But I would rather pay for it, since the medical care we get here is limited.

I can not go to the doctor unless I am bothered with something. If I'm afraid I got something .. doesn't matter, until it affects my life in other forms than ''fear'' the doctor will not examine me.

In a private hospital, I can pay for an examination.

Side: Low Taxes
1 point

This is why government health care is a bad idea.

Just to clarify, do they have private hospitals where you live?

Side: Low Taxes

Yes we do. I use a private hospital, because when I think I'm ill I want to be examined. I also use a private school, since they are much much better.

Side: Low Taxes
1 point

Screw the economy... low taxes are better for me!

Side: Low Taxes
1 point

Why is that? Doesn't that mean that the government is weaker or something?

Side: Low Taxes
AbbyNestor(1028) Disputed
1 point

No. It means less burdens on the state. It gives more to the public and reduces the amount of money they can legally steal from us. You know. Because taxation is theft. These are my beliefs of course but hey. I think they are right.

Side: High Taxes
1 point

That is a really good point, OddHannah.

That is, of course, provided you are being sarcastic.

Side: Low Taxes
Hellno(17753) Disputed
1 point

What's wrong with a weaker government?

Side: High Taxes
1 point

Lower taxes help the economy. When you have lower taxes, employers can pay their employees more, and the consumer can buy more things with the excess money. It would help the economy to lower taxes and let it take its natural course, instead of higher taxes and relying on the government to bail you out, with your own money. Some businesses would fail in the beginning due to lost government funding, but others would pop up in their place once people started to buy stuff again. A flat tax all around would be a nice start, say around what you said of 5-9%. Truthfully, I feel I shouldn't pay the government more than I pay God.

Side: Low Taxes
1 point

A low tax. I feel like I deserve to have some more money in my pockets.

Side: Low Taxes
1 point

I choose this one because you say the other one is crazy.

Side: Low Taxes

No more stuff that is not really useful!

Side: Low Taxes

Low tax rates equals savings and productive means of resources while high taxes equals spending and consumptive means of resources.

Savings and Production equals job creation.

Side: Low Taxes
OddHannah(313) Disputed
1 point

So why are people still losing jobs if these companies have tax breaks?

Side: High Taxes
1 point

Because it wasn't the tax breaks, it was the artificial demand created by low interest and the printing press. Inflation caught up.

Side: Low Taxes
1 point

Low taxes. Democrats need to stop taxing everything. .

Side: Low Taxes