CreateDebate


Debate Info

9
7
Starwars Lord of the Rings
Debate Score:16
Arguments:11
Total Votes:17
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Starwars (5)
 
 Lord of the Rings (6)

Debate Creator

fwc67(123) pic



Which was a better trilogy?

Excluding the new Starwars and Hobbit

Starwars

Side Score: 9
VS.

Lord of the Rings

Side Score: 7
3 points

Star Wars for sure! I mean Lord of the rings has magic but no guns WTF!!!

Side: Starwars
13028699(46) Disputed
1 point

who needs guns for a good plot? Swords and bows and arrows and axes are WAY better

Side: lord of the rings
2 points

The Star Wars story is way bigger and more complex than Lord of the Rings. All of the movies Included the clone wars animations, maybe cover 10% of the whole Star Wars saga. Star Wars facinated a lot of people by the story, complexibility and awesomeness. Just the idea of the laserswords and lightspeed from 1974 is amazing. These are classics where Lord of the Rings has no chance!

Side: Starwars
clearEn(207) Disputed
1 point

Honestly, when it comes to 'classics', LOTR is far more 'classic' than Star Wars. Tolkein redefined and spurred a whole new genre into action. As for Star Wars, even though the books and story may be good, I think Star Trek took the Sci-Fi genre off instead.

Also, I don't mean to be mean, but it brought a smile to my face. You wrote the word (or non-word) 'complexibility'. I thought it was funny (not in a bad way. New words are fine, especially when they're just suffixes and prefixes added to them!)

Side: lord of the rings
1 point

Star Wars is just awesome nobody can beat it. Sure tha animation from Lord of the Rings is high tech, Star Wars is a classic.

Side: Starwars
1 point

Star Wars! LOTRs sucked balls... just a bunch of chasing around and the ending was terrible.

Side: Starwars
1 point

I would say Star Wars. Good acting, the effects are pretty cool and its a classic. I never understood Lord of the Rings. Also starwars has something lord of the rings doesn't have... the force and some guns....and for sure it doesn't have this huge battle station that can destroy planets...I would say it is the best series of movies made. :D

Side: Starwars

I love them both but Lord of the Rings is my favorite.

Side: lord of the rings
1 point

Star Wars is based on materialistic things and fan boys. Lord of the rings actually has fantastic directing, and in my opinion much better story telling. Star wars is all about the money.

Side: lord of the rings

I chose this side because Star Wars is not a trilogy. What are they up to now; 5 movies? ;)

Side: lord of the rings
0 points

Lord of the Rings rules. Star wars is not interesting. LOTR has is complex, complete with a history of Middle Earth and languages for each of the races. It is WAY MORE believeable and engaging. Star wars on the other hand is CRAP

Side: lord of the rings