CreateDebate


Debate Info

Debate Score:21
Arguments:19
Total Votes:25
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Who is going to win American Idol 2008? (19)

Debate Creator

lauraorme(128) pic



Who is going to win American Idol 2008?

Add New Argument
3 points
I think David Archuleta is a little teen dream -- I see every Zac Efron fan in America falling in love with him. And he's just plain good. But I can't stop listening to Jason Castro's rendition of 'Daydream' (yeah, I downloaded it) and found some youtube videos of him live pre-Idol. He's pretty mesmerizing vocally and on the guitar.
Jason Castro performing 'Crazy' pre-Idol
3 points
I agree Kori! David Archuleta is so cute. He seems so sweet and innocent too and is always very happy to get complements! Maybe he's faking, but I'm definitely falling for it!
1 point
Damn...that guy is better than I thought. Pretty good performance.
2 points
Kady Malloy is definitely going to be the 2008 American Idol.
Supporting Evidence: Kady Malloy (www.americanidol.com)
2 points
David Archuleta is the man. He's definitely going to win.
Supporting Evidence: David's profile (www.americanidol.com)
2 points
FYI - Check out the profiles before adding your argument.
Supporting Evidence: Official Profiles (www.americanidol.com)
2 points
I think Paula wants to win this year!!!
Supporting Evidence: Paula Abdul's New Music Video (www.fox.com)
1 point
Michael Johns is going to run away with Idol this year. The voting audience isn't going to make the same mistake they did with Chris Daughtry and let the best performer get voted off.
2 points
I agree - he was awesome during the Hollywood week. His bohemian rhapsody was so good!
NikkiHill11(154) Disputed
0 points
Although Chris Daughtry is great, Carrie Underwood is better and deserved to win AI that season. Both were top selling artists in 2007, however Carrie's debut album was certified 7x platinum and is the fastest selling debut country album in Nielsen SoundScan history. 'Some Hearts' sold a total of 7 million Recording Industry Association of America-certified copies as of February 2008, it is now the best-selling solo female debut in country music history ever.
Supporting Evidence: Source (en.wikipedia.org)
korihill06(124) Disputed
0 points
Chris Daughtry was the season of Taylor Hicks and Katharine McPhee -- not Carrie Underwood. I do believe he should have won that year.
1 point
I have to put in a vote for Brooke White. Did you see her on tonight's show....with the Beatles song? She was awesome.
Please kick off Amanda Overmyer!!!!! Ugh!
1 point

I definitely have changed my opinion from the beginning of the competition. David Cook is for sure the winner! Did you see him sing the Billie Jean Remix?!?! If not check it out below!

Billie Jean
0 points
I agree with Kori however, the Harley rocker chick is pretty damn good. I'm really feeling the Janis Joplin/Bob Seger feel.
0 points
David Archuleta!!! Love him!!!