CreateDebate


Debate Info

16
18
Professor Xavier Magneto
Debate Score:34
Arguments:3
Total Votes:48
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Professor Xavier (1)
 
 Magneto (3)

Debate Creator

Sophisto(32) pic



Who is right?

Idealism versus Realism. Naive or cynical? Optimistic or skeptical? Peace or war? Equality or superiority? 

Professor Xavier

Side Score: 16
VS.

Magneto

Side Score: 18
No arguments found. Add one!
1 point

He's usually right about preemptive defense of his fellow mutants. Whether he is committing self-fulfilling prophecies about offensive tactics against non-mutant hostiles is open to interpretation.

Supporting Evidence: "Tell Me I'm Wrong" (youtu.be)
Side: Magneto

Professor doesn't understand he can't make peace with the violent Humans. Magneto is trying to tell him, but Xsavier is arrogant. So Magneto just wants to Kill those violent humans which is most of them.

Side: Magneto
1 point

Killing humans would only lead to a cycle of hatred which would go on forever. The loved ones of Magneto`s victims would try to kill him and if they do, his children would try to avenge him. Therefore the cycle will go on forever until nobody knows what started their dispute in the first place. Look at it this way, if world war 2 never ended the present generation would still be fighting against each other even though the ones who started the trigger were gone forever. Therefore something must be done to stop this cycle of hate, either both sides get eradicated or both would work together for a better future.

Side: Professor Xavier