CreateDebate


Debate Info

Debate Score:16
Arguments:11
Total Votes:17
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Who is rock's all-time greatest guitarist? (11)

Debate Creator

heelspider(109) pic



Who is rock's all-time greatest guitarist?

Chime in if you have an axe to grind
Add New Argument
2 points

I know this will not be the winner, but my vote goes to Keith Richards. Sure, there are probably a thousand guitarists that can play faster or more complicated stuff; but in the end, isn't it about who sounds the best?

While tons of other guitarists have come and gone, Richards keeps laying down fat riff after fat riff. Look at "Satisfaction" from the 60's, "Gimme Shelter" from the 70's, "Start Me Up" from the 80's, and "Saint of Me" from the 90's. And he's still going strong today. . .

Sure, it takes a lot of skill to play fast. But a rarer, and more important skill, is the ability to play something simple and make it sound awesome. Nobody can take a simple riff and make it sound better than Richards.

2 points

Jimi Hendrix. You don't just have to take my word for it either. Check out Rolling Stone's Ranking of the Top 100 Guitarists of All Time.

The article says it better than I can:

"What he played was fucking loud but also incredibly lyrical and expert. He managed to build this bridge between true blues guitar — the kind that Eric Clapton had been battling with for years and years — and modern sounds, the kind of Syd Barrett-meets-Townshend sound, the wall of screaming guitar sound that U2 popularized. He brought the two together brilliantly."

Jimi Hendrix Rocking the Star Spangled Banner
1 point

I highly, highly recommend Hendrix's BBC recordings if you can find them. Plus, I am very pleased that Syd Barrett's name got a least mentioned somewhere in this debate.

2 points

How can you not mention David Gilmour from Pink Floyd? If you love guitar solo's check out the video below. Pretty incredible solos (and of course Gilmour's is #1)

Top 5 Guitar Solos of All Time

I don't know why Jimmy Page isn't up here yet...He's a freaking GOD! I mean, just watch this video..its amazing!

Jimmy Page violin bow solo

Eddie Van Halen. Hands-down. You can't beat Eruption.

ERUPTION
geoff(738) Disputed
1 point

It's empty and soulless, the product of an idiot savant. The only musical value is the classical melody he lifted. I doubt his technical ability would stand up to the likes of someone like Goran Sollscher even with all the special effects which supplement his performance.

1 point

Mark Knopfler should be in the discussion

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oFX7zVXlypc

1 point

Jimi Hendrix or Santana are the 2 greatest guitarists of all time in my personal opinion. Most kids now would say the guitarists from Dragonforce -.- that saddens me. Jimi and Santana are both neck and neck to me, they were always jammin out great vibes and the sounds they made with those guitars were and still are heaven to my ears =]

Side: Jimi Hendrix or Carlos Santana
1 point

i'll say orianthi..she's so cool, and her guitar solos blows me up!! i also think that its so cool that she was mj's last guitar player..she rocks!!

Side: Jimi Hendrix or Carlos Santana

Jimi Hendrix can't be beat. No one could reach the loud notes on the guitar he played.

Side: Jimi Hendrix or Carlos Santana