CreateDebate


Debate Info

7
4
Federal government States government
Debate Score:11
Arguments:12
Total Votes:14
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Federal government (7)
 
 States government (3)

Debate Creator

MAC42(5) pic



Who should control marriage policy?


Federal government

Side Score: 7
VS.

States government

Side Score: 4
No arguments found. Add one!
2 points

Government should manage contract law, and that should be the extent of their interest in the consensual relations between adults.

Side: States government
outlaw60(15368) Disputed
1 point

You have no clue as to why government got into marriage and your stupid response proves that you have no clue !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Does your Google work there idiot ???????

Side: Federal government
Amarel(5669) Disputed
1 point

Sure I do smart guy. The government claimed that society has a stake in the ways and means by which it’s future generations are created and raised, thus justifying government management of those ways and means via marriage. But a free society cannot be subject to government management on such personal private matters without a significant reduction of said freedom. It’s not that I have no clue, it’s that I disagree. But I don’t mind seeing your arguments on par with Noms. Keep it up champ.

Side: States government

There should be no marriage policy, why should the state have anything to do with who people want to marry?

And why is marriage even a thing?

Side: States government
outlaw60(15368) Disputed
1 point

Check up on marriage then get back to me !!!!!!!!!

Is that going to be a challenge for you ????????????

Side: Federal government
1 point

There should be no marriage policy, why should the state have anything to do with who people want to marry?

Because if a woman gets into an agreement where she doesn't get a job to care for the kids, then years later the man changes the rules of the situation and leaves, she's really screwed, and it's his fault in part, due to their agreement, for her having no accumulation of wealth, resources, education, job skills, etc., thus he is legaly bound to help her.

And why is marriage even a thing?

Because it's the most stable environment to raise up children in if you're going to have them.

Side: Federal government
Pedestrian(151) Clarified
2 points

What concerns you has been going on for millenia. What about it ?

You should state your own 'new' marriage policy and tell your state govt., the major govt. that sanctions marriage.

Side: Federal government