CreateDebate


Debate Info

6
7
Spiderman Batman
Debate Score:13
Arguments:10
Total Votes:16
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Spiderman (4)
 
 Batman (6)

Debate Creator

sonic123(330) pic



Who would win in a fight Spiderman or Batman

I've seen a lot of their movies and want to find out who's better, they both are MARVELS.Smile

Spiderman

Side Score: 6
VS.

Batman

Side Score: 7
2 points

Spiderman wins this , there certain thing to consider when you are talking about superheroes . Strength , speed , intelligence , durability , reflexes , fighting skill , healing factor , experience , gadgets , environmental control , stealth , and weaknesses .

Spiderman

Strength : 10 tons

Speed : 200 mph

Intelligence : 250 IQ

Durability : Took a semi truck to the face that thrown by venom so fast that he could not dodges . Normal humans would break their hands punching him.

Reflexes : 15 times faster than human . He dodges bullets from automatic weapons.

Fighting Skill : way of the spider combines his martial arts training with his spider sense , strength , speed , and reflexes .

Healing Factor : Can heal wounds faster than humans with his proportional spider abilities .

Experience : He is very experienced as he has faced many villains.

Gadgets : Webbing can with strain the Hulk . Combined with his reflexes he can put up a web wall fast enough to block bullets .

Environmental Control : Wall crawling and webshooting give him extraordinary control over the battle field .

Stealth : While he isn't exactly a master of this his spider sense cancels out the enemies ability to use stealth .

Weaknesses : Spiderman has no true weaknesses except overconfidence .

Batman

Strength : 1500 pounds

Speed : 30 mph

Intelligence : 190 IQ

Durability : Got his back broken by Bane

Reflexes : peak human

Fighting Skill : 127 martial arts

Healing Factor : Human

Experience : 127 martial arts , league of assassin's training , and defeating many villains

Gadgets : Many non-lethal gadgets . Most are thrown however and travel slowly.

Environmental Control : his gliding and grappling hook give him some good environmental control.

Stealth : ninja

Weaknesses : magic , ranged weapons , human restrictions.

Overall

Strength : Spiderman ( 10 tons > 1500 pounds )

Speed : Spiderman ( 200 mph > 30 mph )

Intelligence : Batman ( he can apply his knowledge better than Spiderman , but not by much )

Durability : Spiderman ( Venom > Bane )

Reflexes : Spiderman ( Batman dodges bullets by dodging the barrel , something normal soldiers can do . Spiderman dodges the actual bullets after they have been fired)

Fighting Skill : Spiderman ( The spider sense combined with superior strength and speed trump 127 martial arts )

Healing Factor : Spiderman (super human beats human )

Experience : Batman ( batman stomps in this big time )

Gadgets : Spiderman ( his webs can neutralize all of batman's gadgets)

Environmental Control : Spiderman ( Wall crawling and webs beat gliding and grappling hooks )

Stealth : Batman ( this doesnt matter cause spider sense )

Weaknesses : Spiderman ( Spiderman has none bat man has several )

Spiderman : 9 Batman : 2 ( would be three but stealth is useless in this fight ) Overall Spiderman wins .

Side: Spiderman
2 points

As a comic geek myself I very much appreciate the thought, detail and research you put into this (assuming you didn't Copy and paste from somewhere else.) I fully agree with the assessment.

What drives me crazy is that even though you have all this good information, you did not ONCE spell Spider-Man's name correctly. It has never been "Spiderman".

Side: Spiderman
1 point

Also , no one supporting batman has given a logical reason as to why bat man would win . They said Spiderman would lose because they like bat man better . Non a very logical argument . I like bat man more , I really do . But that's why I know batman would lose . And sorry about spelling Spider-Man wrong . Auto correct sucks and I didn't want to correct every time I wrote Spider-Man .

Side: Spiderman

Batman would win any given day of the week.

First, Batman is more realistic.

Side: Batman
Debater345(170) Disputed
1 point

The fact that he is more realistic means he loses . Spider-Man has superior strength and speed . batman's stealth is countered by spider sense . Overall , I'd say bat man has a 2.5% chance of winning and that's being nice considering how powerful Spider-Man is . He has been so downplayed over the years while batman has been upped .

Side: Spiderman
1 point

Batman was my favorite superhero before it was cool to like Batman, better than the other superheros at least.

1. This has been a comic, and when aliens took the brains of every superhero, who saved them all with his superior intelligence? Batman, that's who.

2. While the newest Batman movies are the coolest superhero movies ever, they vastly overlook his intelligence. If you're true to the comics, he's not just an acceptionally bright playboy with an overactive sense of justice, he's supposed to be a complete genius. Like can beat Grand Masters at chess genius.

Now, I'll happily admit in a cage match, Superman, Wonderwoman, Spiderman, Green Lantern, Flash, etc, etc, etc, would kick his ass.

However, life is not a cage match, and if there were ever a true superhero, he or she could only be so if born in Batman's particular situation, and blessed with both exceptional mental and physical prowess.

And that is why I like Batman. A combination of realism and badass-ness.

Side: Batman

I love both, but Batman has the brains, the brawn, and the gadgets. Spiderman has the advantage of having superpowers (especially his spidey sense), but he is limited in the fact that he is a teenager without much resources.

Side: Batman

I say Batman because Bruce Wayne is more intelligent and he has the prowess to defeat an opponent.

Side: Batman
0 points
Side: Batman
0 points

this is how it would all go down:

http://video.nationalgeographic.com/video/player/animals/bugs-animals/spiders-and-scorpions/spider_orb_kills_bat.html

spider man though a nerd, albeit, would totally take batman out :)

Supporting Evidence: Spider takes out the bat (video.nationalgeographic.com)
Side: Spiderman