CreateDebate


Debate Info

Debate Score:43
Arguments:19
Total Votes:43
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Why Do People Hate America??? (19)

Debate Creator

mitgag(1652) pic



Why Do People Hate America???

Add New Argument
4 points

It is neither our 'diversity,' nor our 'freedom' that other nations resent and despise. It is our history of systematic oppression and imperialism. This imperialism has manifested itself not only through overt military means, but also through economic policies, religious missions, and the destruction of indigenous cultures around the world.

We live as well as we do in this country because we have exploited and hurt those in other parts of the world. Others will deny this, ignorantly assuming that other nations hate us for our virtues (ie, "freedom" and "diversity"), while in reality if they do hate us, their feelings are at least justified.

Side: Our Imperialism
trumpeter93(998) Disputed
2 points

Hate comes from jealously and fear.

overt military means

that is a matter of perspective

religious missions

We have freedom of religion.

the destruction of indigenous cultures around the world

Social Darwinism. Those who cannot adapt to changing environments will die off.

We live as well as we do in this country because we have exploited and hurt those in other parts of the world.

We are not the only country in history to do this. And again, this is a matter of perspective. Somebody living below the poverty line in the United States would not see their life being well.

Side: Our Imperialism
Swryght(161) Disputed
2 points

"that is a matter of perspective"

What perspective would deny that our overt military actions are probably part of the reason why other nations "hate" the U.S.? It must surely be a perspective with its head in the sand.

"we have freedom of religion"

Our freedom of religion applies to how we may behave in this country, and even then it refers to our freedom to practice religion. It certainly does not give us the right to impose our religions on those in other nations.

"Social Darwinism. Those who cannot adapt to changing environments will die off."

Social Darwinism has long been associated with imperialistic philosophies. Thank you for proving my point. The essence of this debate is, "why do people hate America?" Well, if Americans see the destruction of other cultures in the name of social Darwinism, then certainly that would be cause for some frustration on the part of those being destroyed.

"We are not the only country in history to do this. And again, this is a matter of perspective. Somebody living below the poverty line in the United States would not see their life being well."

Just because we are not the only country to have behaved in this way, does not in any way imply that this behavior would not incite hatred in those from other nations. Also, I think any fair comparison of poverty in this country compared to that in third-world nations would reveal that even an impoverished American is relatively wealthy compared to an impoverished Indian.

Side: Our Imperialism
4 points

Some reasons I might list from recent memory:

The United States has produced a culture of superiority, that believes it is the best without being supported by most facts.

The United States typically pressures other natures for political policies to be embraced (such as copyright mirroring the DMCA) but generally refuses to take part in major multilateral efforts (those involved in climate change, Kyoto Protocol for example).

The United States has a very terrible record of meddling in other sovereign nations' affairs, inciting war, ousting leaders via coup, causing instability, and especially putting dictators into power who they themselves had become mass murderers.

The United States is the only nation to detonate a nuclear warhead in a city inhabited by civilians, not once but twice.

The United States monitors all international communications signals via ECHELON. This rightly concerns privacy advocates overseas.

The United States gave birth to many multinational corporations, and the corporate culture, and is blamed for a very bad kind of globalisation that destroys local cultures of other countries.

Side: Our Imperialism
3 points

They hate us because we meddle in the affairs of others. We try to impose our systems and believes on everyone else, claiming that these are the best methods, systems, etc. A country that is only two hundred years old and telling nations that have been around for thousands of years what they should do, and you would why were hated.

Side: Our Imperialism

America is just name attached to a piece of land where people come together and share the same basic ideals. It is impposible to hate land. Land is esstienal to life.

However, the hatred is our ideals and culture, particularly freedom and liberty.

Side: Freedom and Liberty
Swryght(161) Disputed
2 points

"However, the hatred is our ideals and culture, particularly freedom and liberty."

Why would anyone hate liberty? I think your argument could use some supporting reasoning or evidence. I think that if you are correct, then you are correct only insofar as we as Americans use our liberty to walk all over others.

Would a nation of liberty detain prisoners of war without charges?

Would a nation of liberty torture prisoners while condemning the torture conducted by other nations?

Would a nation of liberty kill 100,000 civilians to "liberate" them? http://www.iraqbodycount.org/

Side: Our Imperialism
2 points

Why would anyone hate liberty?

Those who want to oppress it.

I think that if you are correct, then you are correct only insofar as we as Americans use our liberty to walk all over others.

That is fair.

Liberty is not given or forced, it is earned. America earned its liberty from the monarchy of English power. Liberty only comes at a personal level while oppression only comes at the societal level.

Therefore, we must separte liberty from force and personal from government. Government only has only tool and that is force; hence, liberty also has only one tool, voluntary.

Would a nation of liberty detain prisoners of war without charges?

Would a nation of liberty torture prisoners while condemning the torture conducted by other nations?

Would a nation of liberty kill 100,000 civilians to "liberate" them?

This is not the idea of liberty. This is the idea of government abuse. I would never condone the actions of torture. It is simply government power and depriving those of liberty.

Side: Our Imperialism
2 points

We're the most diverse nation in the world. We have more ethnicities, cultures, religions and lifestyles than any other country.

They're obviously prejudice.

Side: Our Diversity
Swryght(161) Disputed
3 points

Your argument is invalid. Here is the logical form of your argument:

Premise 1: We are a diverse nation.

Conclusion: Therefore, other nations hate us.

The reason this is invalid is that the conclusion does not follow logically from the premise. Your argument follows the same logical form as this one, which I think you will agree is invalid:

Premise 1: Wal-mart sells many different products.

Conclusion: Therefore, other stores hate Wal-mart.

In order to make your argument valid, you need to flesh it out with supporting evidence. What evidence do you have that these other nations despise diversity? If you do have such evidence, then how do you know that other factors, such as imperialism and oppression, are not playing a role in the hatred?

Side: Our Imperialism
ThePyg(6738) Disputed
2 points

well, I was obviously joking, but if you're going to be a prick, I guess I can get logical.

There's no objective measurement of hatred or why someone would hate something, therefore this question is invalid.

Thus, any serious answer to this question would be invalid.

All based on logic, of course.

Side: Our Diversity
2 points

One word where all hate comes from...................................... jealousy

Side: Our Diversity
2 points

People hate America when they:

1) have the preconception that 'hate' can apply to nations,

2) are in conflict with it,

3) disagree with it's ideals, and/or,

4) were brought to the position via external influence

AND

1) feel strongly enough to characterise 'hate', and

2) are unable to find relative good in it.

Side: Our Diversity
2 points

people dont usually hate america. i talked to a lot of iraqi guys and i thought to myself, these guys must hate america because american soldiers have torn their country to shreds, killed god knows how many of their friends, and family member, yet these guys seem to be quite forgiving of their oppressors and find forgiveness. i am quite impressed with the people who have been abused by america. it seems to me that most of the hate is coming from within america and not outside it. ive also talked to alot of chinese people, and most of them seem to have good things to say about america, despite all the horrible things that amerians say about the chinese. i have also talked to numerous vietnamese who had their country torn apart by u.s. troops. the american soldiers dropped more bombs on viet nam than all of world war 2 combined, yet i havent heard an ounce of hate come out of the viets. mexicans havent dropped a single bomb on america, but look at the amount of hatred that americans have towards them.

Side: Our Diversity

Some people in other countries hate America because they are jealous that most people have it better off in this country than they do.

Side: Our Diversity