CreateDebate


Debate Info

3
1
Yeah! Black Holes Rock! Boo! Black Holes Suck!
Debate Score:4
Arguments:4
Total Votes:4
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Yeah! Black Holes Rock! (3)
 
 Boo! Black Holes Suck! (1)

Debate Creator

iamdavidh(4856) pic



Black Holes, What's Up With That?

Here's the most common definition: http://cosmology.berkeley.edu/Education/BHfaq.html#q1 (and there's a bunch of other good junk around that site, I like it because it makes things simple without dumbing it down too much, if you're interested in such things)

On the one hand it's probably the most mysterious, awe inspiring, imagination igniting thing known to man right now.

On the other, it destroys everything in it's path, and chances are somewhere in the center of our cluster of galaxies lies a massive black hole that will swallow all but the furthest stars (ours not being one of the furthest)

Yeah! Black Holes Rock!

Side Score: 3
VS.

Boo! Black Holes Suck!

Side Score: 1
1 point

Sure, they're dark, mysterious, and destroy anything in their path,

but so do ninjas, and everyone knows that ninjas are cool :)

Side: Yeah! Black Holes Rock!

Black holes are the most METAL things IN THE UNIVERSE!!!!!!!!! What could possibly be more metal than disfragmenting planets?

Side: Yeah! Black Holes Rock!
1 point

I mean, really, it's a huge ball of gravity and AWESOME. Clearly they are rockin'. This is no debate!

Side: Yeah! Black Holes Rock!
1 point

humbug.

one generally excepted Truth of the universe is that it always has the same amount of "stuff" in it. Mass can change to energy, energy to mass, either into something in between called plasma. Things can get bigger and smaller. But the amount is always the same.

If one burns a book, you can't read it any more, but all of the properties exist in some form or another, whether floating around the atmosphere as smoke, or ashes on the ground,

I look at a black hole like that, it just kind of messes stuff up.

I'm thinking of going to a town hall, and shouting how black holes are nazi-socialists and they weren't even born in the US anyway :)

Side: Boo! Black Holes Suck!