CreateDebate


Debate Info

19
25
They know not what they do They don’t deserve aid
Debate Score:44
Arguments:19
Total Votes:61
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 They know not what they do (7)
 
 They don’t deserve aid (12)

Debate Creator

Slavedevice(1257) pic



Why should climate deniers get hurricane aid?

Climate change deniers are like science deniers.  If yo deny science then you shouldn’t get medical attention when you are sick.  Fuck em, they re on their own.  They deserve it.

They know not what they do

Side Score: 19
VS.

They don’t deserve aid

Side Score: 25
5 points

Why should climate deniers get hurricane aid?

Name one person on the entire planet who denies climate.

Side: They know not what they do
1 point

Why should socialists, living in America, enjoy the benefits of Capitalism?

Side: They know not what they do
1 point

If yo deny science then you shouldn’t get medical attention when you are sick.

Hello S:

The question - why should we treat terrorists well, when they DON'T treat us well - is asked here all the time..

The answer is, we act like Americans because we're AMERICANS... And, we do it whether our adversary deserves it or not..

excon

Side: They don’t deserve aid
joker43 Disputed
2 points

The question - why should we treat terrorists well, when they DON'T treat us well - is asked here all the time..

The answer is, we act like Americans because we're AMERICANS

No it isn't you goddamned lunatic. Americans are among the largest exporters of mass scale terrorism in the entire world. When the military invaded Iraq, civilians were raped, tortured and killed, and the water and power supplies were cut (in some cases for up to 6 months). Americans are shielded from all other opinions except American opinions, and so most of them have no idea they are considered terrorists by most of the rest of the world. Your culture exists in a sandbox.

Side: They know not what they do
Grugore(849) Disputed
1 point

Come on, dude. Let's see your proof. Or are you simply talking out your stinky ass?

Side: They don’t deserve aid
Grugore(849) Disputed
0 points

Well now. Those are pretty serious accusations. Got any proof?

Side: They don’t deserve aid
1 point

Hello Excon.

The answer is, we act like Americans because we're AMERICANS... And, we do it whether our adversary deserves it or not..

Well said.

Mostly.

I agree that ideas and beliefs are not qualifiers for participation in any aspect of America, nor to have access to any benefits of being an American.

However, I disagree that people who are skeptical that the hurricanes are the result of climate change (or even that there are more hurricanes now than a century ago) or that people are the cause of climate change are the adversaries of the people who think there are more hurricanes now than previously, and that people are the cause of the climate change (despite the fact that the Anthropogenic Climate Change hypothesis remains unproven.)

The only way science can work well is that some people try to disprove a hypothesis, and some people try to prove the hypothesis. Without both sets of people and expectations, the scientific process does not work reliably.

Believers and skeptics NEED each other. The two groups are not adversaries, but allies.

Side: They don’t deserve aid