CreateDebate


Debate Info

2
5
Take guns Arm up
Debate Score:7
Arguments:18
Total Votes:8
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Take guns (1)
 
 Arm up (5)

Debate Creator

KittenGirl(142) pic



Would a Fascist want to take your guns or to arm yourself against a fascist government?

Take guns

Side Score: 2
VS.

Arm up

Side Score: 5
1 point

Take guns.

Now ask what a social democrat would do and you'll realise that this isn't solely about Fascism at all. Do you think your semi automatic will save you from the machine guns and propaganda that the government can use against you? The only time the second amendment was ever use was in the confederates vs Lincoln civil war and it was wielded by rabid racists fighting for their "right to keep slaves".

Side: Take guns
1 point

Take guns.

That's objectively false. Hitler did the precise opposite. There had been a total gun ban under the Weimar Republic, which Hitler overturned.

Side: Arm up
SunTzuv2(35) Clarified
1 point

No he didn't, he simply altered the ban to not include who he selected.

Side: Take guns
SunTzuv2(35) Clarified
1 point

All Fascist regimes, whether Italy in WW2 or modern day Brazil etc, eventually aim to remove guns from the citizens. Whether they succeed or not is a different matter.

Side: Take guns

History shows us quite clearly what a fascist would do. Hitler overturned the total gun ban set by the Weimar Republic and began freely distributing guns.

Side: Arm up