perhaps a re-framing of this debate as: suicide girls vrs playboy?

girly-girls can be attractive, and goth girls very unattractive but lets say we're dealing with their sexually ideal presentations; suicide girls win.

Stereotypical categories and why one wins over the other:

Suicide girls:

Tattoos are sexy

confidence is sexy

pale can be sexy as well as tan

I prefer the contrasts of black and black..and green, red, purple white etc over the contrast of pink and white.

girly girls:

indirectness is annoying

overly-high-pitched voices are annoying

orange skin is annoying

anti-intellectualism is annoying

i want a challenge and desire in a women, not someone i can completely control

little dogs should all be squashed.

Imma goth/punk chickie an i think goth girls are WAYYY hotter than girly girls. they're annoying anyways XP

Hay I love goth it`s like

i live with goth I want to talk to u som time how bout right now!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!??????????????

I'm not goth or girly, I come somewhere in the middle. I'm a "sorta kinda reformed suicide girl" aka a tough girl. I know a lot of girly girls that drive me up the wall cuz they act so frikin braindead... they cannot stop giggling or applying multiple layers of makeup, like that's the only thing that matters to them.

IM not really goth but i look like a girly girl. I guess you could say im a bad ass girly girl. I have the innocent face and the punk rock attitude. But i hate girly girls. They act like they better than everyone else, that's how they get cut.

Honestly, I'd rather get to know the girl behind the image. On a superficial level I like the alterna-girl way better "average girls"...but I've met plenty from both sides that defied my normal exceptions, both for good and bad.

That said, I'm an "eclectic" individual. I'm tat'ed up, I listen to obscure music, I live to be myself rather than some image. I don't easily get along with many "normal" folks. So finding a unique little oddball is typically beneficial for me, and often (not always), their style and entertainment tastes can give me a reasonable picture of what type of person I'm dealing with.