CreateDebate


Debate Info

Debate Score:8
Arguments:9
Total Votes:8
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 life puzzle.... (8)

Debate Creator

arey(41) pic



life puzzle....

There are two people A and B. B trusts A and shares his secrets with him.  A tells those secrets to all others. When B asked A why he betrayed him,  A tells that he didn't ask B to trust him in the first place, which is true. Now, speaking with intelligence the reason what A told is true but with an intelligence beyond words to describe, we know that A is the bag guy.

          In life we face many such situations(I truly did). The world isn't always fair towards us because it sees and understands the reasons and logic visible on the outside.

          But even though, we shouldn't give up on life. Tell me one point which you will tell in terms of reason and logic which proves that A is the bad guy and B is the good guy.

Add New Argument
1 point

OK

A is a priest and B believing in the confidentiality of the confessional, confides his secret sins.

So who is the bad guy

A is a doctor who has been treating B for an infection, when B believing he can talk to his Doctor in confidence tells him about his problems that he has kept secret from everyone.

So who is the bad guy

arey(41) Disputed
1 point

You didn't get the point.You are taking about a case where B is at fault(he committed sins).I am taking a case where B is not at fault but he is unable to justify that he is right. Consider A and B to be friends.

1 point

ok let we consider A and B FRIENDS...like every friendship relation B shared his secrets with A.but A betrayed him and told his secrets to everyone and when B complained he cunningly caused B to consider himself at fault..this shows A was cunning thus a bad guy...but how we can say B a good guy just bcoz he trusted someone easily...we can say that it was his weakness

arey(41) Disputed
1 point

Then when will you trust someone, when the the other person tells you "trust me"??

PhilboydStud(79) Clarified
1 point

When someone tells me to trust them small red flags start going up. Trust must be earned.

MARIA55(55) Disputed
1 point

Trusting someone easily is a great weakness of a person...I mean first B should have checked A if he was the right person to share his secrets as many people love gossiping and while doing it they don't see if they are hurting someone.

1 point

B is the bad guy because B gave information to A without asking for confidentiality. No agreement to keep confidentiality was explicit or implied. Then B wrongly accused A of betrayal. Causing A to wet his/her pants and ruin the afternoon.

Further B was initially at fault in unwisely placing his trust in A.

1 point

(After confiding his secrets to A, B should have told A not to forget to tell everyone else that they were secrets, L.O.L.) ;- B's secrets were of such a menacing nature that it was important for everyone to be aware of the threat which B posed to all the others. A made the decision to discard any friendship which may have existed with B for the greater good of all.

I guess B believed too much in A.I would say A is correct.

As for B,he must have ensured he didn't confide too much in sb.Best advice:keep secrets to yourself else you will have to endure the betrayal.