CreateDebate


Debate Info

15
46
percy harry
Debate Score:61
Arguments:24
Total Votes:76
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 percy (9)
 
 harry (15)

Debate Creator

123456789101(86) pic



percy jackson vs harry potter

who would win in a fight

percy

Side Score: 15
VS.

harry

Side Score: 46

well for starter he invincible is the son of a god can summon hurricanes at will.

the son of a god can turn into mist and go really fast. can make water fist

Side: percy
20mholland Banned
1 point

HE IS BETTER BECAUSE HE MAKES BETTER MOVIES AND HE IS A GOD

Side: percy
Arya30(74) Disputed
1 point

He is a HALF GOD .

Side: harry
1 point

He has a sword and he is a water bender. 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50

Side: percy
1 point

He has a sword and he is a water bender. 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50

Side: percy
20evandeneng(11) Disputed
2 points

This has nothing to do with the book or the movies all it has to do with anything with the Percy Jackson series is that he has a sword and some powers. But Harry Potter has better and more powers. Any please tell me what the 50's at the end mean....

Side: harry
20jdriscoll(1) Disputed
1 point

The 50s are so I would have enought words to post. What does harry have, a magical stick that shoots lazer lights. And the movies are bad.

Side: percy

sure the movies sucked @!%& but the books were good and again he is invincuble

Side: percy

in this debate the point is to compare there powres in battle there srenghs and weakness not the movies and books

Side: percy

please do not post according to the movies or books this argument is about who would win in a fight, also dont post things like harry is wizard so he will when or percy is a demigod so he will win you need supporting evidence that Harry/percy will win or you will be baned

thank you

sincerely 123456789101 the debate creator

Side: percy
0 points

I have read both series but Percy Jackson is a lot better in details and length.

Side: percy
Arya30(74) Disputed
1 point

Percy Jackson is a lot better in DETAILS and LENGTH. You just said the exact opposite. HARRY POTTER is the BEST.

Side: harry

I don't like either but Percy Jackson was aimed at young kids. It was what everyone my age used to read when we were like 10. Also the films were total flops.

Side: harry
5 points

I also agree that most of the Harry Potter books and movies were DEFINITELY better than the trash Percy Jackson books and movies.

Side: harry
5 points

I love the Harry Potter series. When reading the first book I couldn't put the book down. Even though it was such a big book I found that it only took me a couple of days to finish the book. There was a great feeling that it gives you and it makes you emotionally attached to the characters. This feeling was not there when I read the Percy Jackson series.

Side: harry
5 points

I Think Harry Potter because based on the ratings, the Harry Potter movies are better, more detailed, and interesting than the Percy Jackson movies.

Side: harry
4 points

I think Harry Potter because he is a real wizard according to the Harry Potter movies and he has magical powers and he is a good role model and he saved Hogwarts from voldemort.

Side: harry
4 points

To even show that the movies are better for the harry potter series, we looked up the ratings and the Harry Potter movies were more detailed and were also better rated at an average of 4/5 stars. While Percy Jackson movies were an adverage of 2.5/5 stars.

Side: harry
20mholland Banned
3 points

Harry is better because he is like a wizard and he made a little better movie.

Side: harry
3 points

I grew up reading these series.

Harry may have graduated from Hogwarts but I will never graduate from loving all the 7 books.

Side: harry
2 points

As much as I love the "The son of Neptune" and "The Last Olympian", I'm gonna have to give this to Harry. Not only is he a more complex character than Percy, the harry potter books are just better written and more in depth. Percy Jackson is a more surface area kind of guy. I enjoy both but I prefer Harry Potter.

Side: harry

I will say Harry Potter because he has the advantage of his wizardry skills.

Side: harry
1 point

Percy Jackson is a book series for younger children (children say 9 to 13) but harry potter is more for advanced readers such as teenagers and adults. The plots are both fantastic but Percy Jackson is better for those who enjoy monsters fighting demigods or gods having children with humans. Harry potter's plot is more interesting and of course the Harry potter books involve wizards fighting wizards and magic.

Now if this argument is based on the main characters and their abilities and not the book series its self then Harry potter would win every single time!. Percy would always lose because magic is stronger the elemental control (Water) and Percy isn't as smart as Harry, Percy is rash and impulsive. Although Percy can wield a sword and shield doesn't mean he can attack of defend against magic, if he wasn't Poseidon's son and instead Hecate's child (Goddess of Magic) then maybe he could defend against magic.

Harry Potter is a more powerful character because of his magical abilities and because he isn't impulsive and reckless. Harry can use a sword but he isn't a good warrior. His magic would defeat Percy before Percy could even move. In a battle of smarts harry would win.

Side: harry
0 points

Percy Jackson is more of a young white glitch,quite timid and looks like a bum,Harry potter,well he's big,goggle eyes are horrendous ,both are quite awful in characters,but again the Percy Jackson movie to me is quite dumb.

Side: harry