CreateDebate


Debate Info

3
8
they sould be annihulated they sould not be anihilated
Debate Score:11
Arguments:11
Total Votes:11
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 they sould be annihulated (3)
 
 they sould not be anihilated (5)

Debate Creator

antz2017(17) pic



should disabled be annihulated

do you feel that disabled people are a burden on our taxes as they take and not give..

they sould be annihulated

Side Score: 3
VS.

they sould not be anihilated

Side Score: 8
1 point

Disabilities come in different degrees in criteria's of minor disabilities to severe disabilities. many Severely disabled cant speak and move and have mental impairments. its wrong to leave that criteria of disabled as they have no real purpose and miss out on opertunities in life just used as teddy bears. i am not talking aboat Steve hawking he had no mental impairment. He is well educated and his qualifications are high but he has the right for suicide

if a baby was blind and deaf born why let it suffer all its life better put it to sleep than paying for it to have a horrible life out of tax

Side: they sould be annihulated
LichPotato(362) Disputed
1 point

Who's to say that children with physical impairments are going to lead horrible lives? Have you never heard of Helen Keller? Further, what "impairments", exactly, should allow a parent to have their child murdered?

I strongly suggest you look into the Eugenics movement, and why it no longer exists, since you're proposing we fulfill one of its aims.

Side: they sould not be anihilated
DBCooper(2194) Clarified
1 point

Steve Hawking has no mental impairment .............. What education does the invalid Steve Hawking have

Side: they sould be annihulated
1 point

A man got poisoned by his wife, he ended up paralyzed, blind and deaf. A fully able man just one day ended up severely disabled to that extent, if he has the mental capacity to make decisions,

he should have the right to end his life.

Side: they sould be annihulated
DBCooper(2194) Clarified
1 point

Ants do you have any information for the scenario you have described ...............

Side: they sould be annihulated
1 point

people wake up have empathy, disabled people im talking aboat cant move, see or hear. How hopeless would you feel if you cant dress and wash yourself or speak your own mind. if they have capacity to make decisions they should hav the right to die if they choose.

People wake up if they dont have mental capacity we must make that decisions out of kindness as you could not stand it being that disabled

Side: they sould be annihulated
DBCooper(2194) Clarified
1 point

Hey Ants can Steve Hawking dress himself or wash himself for that matter even speak his own mind. Should Steve Hawking have the right to die if he chooses.

Side: they sould be annihulated
2 points

Yeah that Stephen Hawking. What a drain on society. .

Side: they sould not be anihilated
1 point

No, but I think people who don't check their spelling and make almost as many mistakes as there are words in their sentence should go back to school. But perhaps I'm being mean.

There are many, many, many disabled persons throughout history who have contributed a great deal to society.

Steven Hawkins, Helen Keller, Beethoven, Stevie Wonder.....look it up. There's quite a few who have done amazing things.

Side: they sould not be anihilated
1 point

How would you feel if you were disabled and you were killed because you were causing a "burden on taxes?"

Side: they sould not be anihilated
1 point

It's essential to approach discussions about disability with empathy and understanding. Instead of focusing on negative perceptions, explore positive initiatives like the activities for adults with disabilities at https://www.gccnyc.org/what-we-offer. These activities foster inclusion, helping individuals contribute meaningfully to society. Let's promote dialogue that highlights the value of diverse abilities and builds a more compassionate community.

Side: they sould not be anihilated