CreateDebate


Debate Info

7
2
yes no
Debate Score:9
Arguments:5
Total Votes:9
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 yes (4)
 
 no (1)

Debate Creator

healthfreak(16) pic



should jedi be a religion

whos idea was it for jedi

yes

Side Score: 7
VS.

no

Side Score: 2

Well...considering it's based off of a work of fiction, it has just as much validity as any other religion ;)

(For those of you who have little to no sense of humor, you can put down your bibles and quit praying for me to be smited, it's called a joke)

Side: yes
2 points

A religion is a system of beliefs and behaviors. Each religion began in a different way, but always with someone laying out those behaviors and specifying those beliefs at some point. That is exactly the foundation of the Jedi system. However, due to it's lack of a blatantly spiritual nature, some would say it is more like Buddhism and less like Western religions. Others argue that it is based on an obviously false premise ("the Force"); this is no more or less valuable than an omniscient/omnipotent deity instilling an unprovable soul into humans.

Side: yes
2 points

It is already recognized as a religion, but under the label "Buddhism". The only thing that separates them is in Buddhism, you try to create NO karma, don't do good, and don't do bad.

The Jedi, though, serve other people. They are selfless, and by taking this position they create karma wether it be positive or negative, and they carry the burden of karma for the well being of other people.

Basically though, it is a socialist buddhism.

Side: Already a religion

ABSOLUTELY YESSSSS!!! for only one reason: jedi's are BAMF!!!!!!!!

Side: yes
2 points

It's only a religion if it isn't true.

Side: No