CreateDebate


Debate Info

18
17
forgiveness punishment
Debate Score:35
Arguments:20
Total Votes:39
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 forgiveness (11)
 
 punishment (9)

Debate Creator

oneaglewings(190) pic



wich is better forgiveness or punishment

is the grace and forgiveness of jesus better than the punishment of hell

forgiveness

Side Score: 18
VS.

punishment

Side Score: 17

why not take forgiveness if a person gives it to you willingly besides who in their right mind would want to be punished

Side: forgiveness
2 points

I suppose it depends which end I'm on... am I being forgiven or punished?

Side: forgiveness
3 points

it is the forgiveness if you believe and punisahment if you dont when you fid proof that he is real whic in this case is he has come back and christians are gone

Side: Punishment
2 points

It is better to forgive someone that is done something to you than rather get punish.

Side: forgiveness
2 points

In reality choosing punishment or forgiveness is relitive to the sevarity of the wrong that has been done to you. For an example- if someone kills your brother, you want them to be punished for it. But, if someone takes your bag, but no damage was done, it's better to forgive rather than punish them for something so petty. Forgiveness is better because it leaves everyone feeling happier in the end, and we could use more happines in todays society and economy.

Side: depends
2 points

forgiveness is better than punishment... because i think that at first we should give a chance for people and forgive them... not to punish.. and of course it depends on situation either you forgive or punish... and I think it depends on person character

Side: forgiveness
1 point

the worst part of this life is punishing someone for something, each person's life is his own business and no one has a right to force him to do something else...

each person has to be alowed to do anything that he wanna do...

Side: forgiveness
1 point

forgive and forget...that is the best thing to do! even for your soul and mind! forgiveness simply shows that you are more superior and more mature! plus when you forgive..you learn to be more open towards your true feelings and end up relieved and in one peace with yourself. put it on yourself, would you want to be forgiven or punished for a sin no matter how small it was? ;)

Side: forgiveness
1 point

forgiveness because it seems that you cant not help to feel bad when you are holding a grudge against someone. it feels like you cant move on in your life without forgiving your enemies for what they did.

Side: forgiveness

Forgiveness wins. A grudge only eats at the heart and can cause cancer.

Side: forgiveness
2 points

It is better to forgive somebody, but if a wrong is so great, then punishment is societally required.

For the religious:

If you do wrong, you can pray for God to save your immortal soul, but your mortal body will be punished - possibly with death, if your wrong is bad enough.

Side: Punishment

i actuallly agree wioth you so good job and im actually christian so you are good

Side: Punishment
1 point

Yeh, your right, but now days, there are lots of serious school problem with punishment.

Teacher cause violence to students. Arn't they?

Side: Punishment
2 points

This one guy has a tatto0 on his neck that says "Swift Forgiveness" which means to me: both

Side: Both
2 points

Every situation, whether you've one wrong or right deserves consequences. If someone does wrong, they deserved to punished. Granted there punishment should only be decided by the severity of their wrongdoing. No matter how minuscule the incident, people should be punished. Forgiveness will only let the person off, and won't be an easy reminder to stop and think before the do wrong again.

Side: Punishment
2 points

When someone commits a crime they should be punished for it. Plain and simple. Though if someone stole your car we shouldn't cut off their wrists and hang them from a tree by their nipples. The punishment should resemble the crime.

Side: Punishment
PrincessDJ(4) Disputed
1 point

While that claim is true, You must also understand not everything needs to be punished. What if someone wronged you and it wasnt really a big deal? Or what if they wronged you and apologized sincerely? Is it still right to punish them out of spite? absolutly not. Forgiveness shows you have morals and know that not everyone can always be perfect.

Side: forgiveness

The only time forgiveness should be considered is if you know the person asking for it ie. family. If you don't know the person you wont know if they really mean the apology or if they are just trying to escape punishment.

Side: Punishment
2 points

but in ordrer to do the right thing then you must forgive everyone not only those you know since there is then bias

Side: forgiveness
1 point

Think of something that is very important to you, your house, your loved ones, your retirement, your dog, your country, your church whatever it is and someone killed or destroyed it. If you truly could forgive someone for that completely and truly you could welcome them into your home and feed them, laugh with them even marry, or make love to them. I can not in all honestly say I would be able to do that (unless i truly know a person and there sincerity) and I don't think Ive ever met a person that could. Its easy to say you could but when it comes down to it could you really do it?

Side: Punishment