CreateDebate



Welcome to CreateDebate!

CreateDebate is a social tool that democratizes the decision-making process through online debate. Join Now!
  • Find a debate you care about.
  • Read arguments and vote the best up and the worst down.
  • Earn points and become a thought leader!

To learn more, check out the FAQ or Tour.



Be Yourself

Your profile reflects your reputation, it will build itself as you create new debates, write arguments and form new relationships.

Make it even more personal by adding your own picture and updating your basics.


Twitter
Twitter addict? Follow us and be the first to find out when debates become popular!


pic
Report This User
Permanent Delete

Allies
View All
None

Enemies
View All
None

Hostiles
View All
None

RSS Dislodge

Reward Points:22
Efficiency: Efficiency is a measure of the effectiveness of your arguments. It is the number of up votes divided by the total number of votes you have (percentage of votes that are positive).

Choose your words carefully so your efficiency score will remain high.
83%
Arguments:7
Debates:0
meter
Efficiency Monitor
Online:


Joined:
7 most recent arguments.
13 points

a great open letter to President-Elect Obama by USC proffesor.

Once, in what was perhaps an unguarded moment, you stated that: "Nobody's suffering more than the Palestinian people". After days of relentless Israeli bombing in the Gaza strip that has already killed over four hundred people, most of them civilians or policemen, and injured more than two thousand, many of whom may yet die for lack of medical supplies and facilities, your words have never rung more true. And yet, so far, your only response to this latest assault on the Palestinians, that the UN Secretary General diplomatically calls “disproportionate”, has been to defend Israel’s right to respond to mostly harmless rocket attacks.

Does this mean that on the long way to the White House you have trimmed your sails and, for the sake of securing the power you will soon assume, fear now to speak truth to power? Does this mean that, unlike Dr. King, your sense of justice is adjustable for the sake of political expedience? Those who supported you from the early days of your primary campaign did so not on account of your response to economic crisis, but because they believed in your sense of justice and your commitment to put an end to business-as-usual in Washington, and because they believed in your genuine desire to shape a new and different world order.

In 1981, while you were an undergraduate at Occidental College, you were among the first of a courageous group of students and faculty who, while the cause was still unpopular or unheard of, spoke out for divestment from the apartheid regime in South Africa. You knew then that it was imperative to place pressure on a racist regime which shamefully oppressed a black and coloured population that was discriminated against, subject to pass laws and control of its every movement, parceled into Bantustans, and subject to detention, torture and extra-judicial execution. When the black population protested, like the school children of Soweto, they could be summarily shot down by police or army. The ANC, under Nelson Mandela, was proscribed as a terrorist movement, its leaders were imprisoned, tortured or killed, its guerillas faced the overwhelming power of the South African army, equipped and trained in part by the United States and its European allies. A regime that was so unafraid to use violence in the defense of its discriminatory and racist regime, and so unashamed to do so in the face of international condemnation, could only understand the language of force. The divestment movement in which you so actively participated understood that the euphemistically and cynically named policy of “constructive engagement” was a moral and practical failure and that only the non-violent pressure of a financial boycott on the South African regime had any hope of bringing an end to apartheid without an horrific bloodbath.

Public figures as diverse as Bishop Desmond Tutu and President Jimmy Carter have recognized that Israel too is an apartheid regime, in practice if not in name. South Africa, now a functioning multi-racial democracy, was a white state for a white people. Israel is a Jewish state for a Jewish people. Its non-Jewish, mostly Palestinian Arab citizens are discriminated against in numerous ways, economically and civilly. The dispossessed and ethnically cleansed Palestinian populations, dispersed in the diaspora and in the refugee camps of Gaza, the West Bank and Lebanon, are denied the internationally recognized right of return. They have had their lands and homes taken from them by armed and “legal” force, are subject to collective punishment, prolonged states of siege, the absolute and deliberately destructive control of their daily movements. Where South Africa instituted the pass laws, the checkpoints that have proliferated all over the West Bank and at the exits from Gaza prevent students from reaching their schools and hospitals, workers from reaching their places or work, keep farmers from their fields, the sick from the few hospitals that survive to serve them. The illegal settlements, that in contravention of all international laws regarding occupation have proliferated across the West Bank, are designed to be permanent “facts on the ground” and have divided recognized Palestinian territory into segmented islets, into besieged Bantustans, with the intent of preventing a contiguous Palestinian state. A so-called security wall, illegally built, as even the Israeli Supreme Court recognized, on Palestinian territory, has cut farmers from their lands and turned formerly prosperous villages into isolated prisons. Regular Israeli military incursions into Palestinian cities and refugee camps, and bombings from the air, have killed innumerable civilians, many of them children. Since the election of Hamas, in fair and open elections, Israel has subjected the civilian population of Gaza to a prolonged state of siege, designed to suffocate them into submission, depriving them at will of water and power, medical supplies and food, and of access to the outside world. The most recent, all-out assault on Gaza, the disproportionate and bloody use of excessive force, is no act of self-defense, but the dramatic extension of an insidious policy of extermination of a people that refuses to disappear.

Every one of these acts is a crime against humanity. In their ensemble, they constitute one of the most massive, ethnocidal atrocities of modern times. Alone among nations, Israel acts in flagrant violation of international law and UN resolutions and does so with impunity. That it can do so is in large part the consequence of the uncritical support offered to Israel by a succession of American administrations. Without the military and economic aid of the United States, which amounts to more than a third of all US foreign aid, Israel could not have mounted its violent offensives against the Palestinians or Lebanon, could not maintain its security apparatus, could not afford the illegal settlements that seek to expand Israel into what remains of Palestinian territory. The United States has supplied the F-16s that are bombarding the Palestinians, their schools, police stations and mosques, and the cluster bombs that continue to kill and maim children and farmers in southern Lebanon. America continues to support Israel to the tune of billions every year at the expense of US taxpayers and at the expense of its moral standing in the world.

You will continue to do so, according to your own web page, because “our first and incontrovertible commitment in the Middle East must be to the security of Israel, America's strongest ally in the region.” You and your Vice-President, Joe Biden, not only “defend and support the annual foreign aid package that involves both military and economic assistance to Israel”, but moreover “have advocated increased foreign aid budgets to ensure that these funding priorities are met.” In doing so, you lend your support, in the name of the United States, to a regime no less criminal in its acts and in its policies towards its own minority population and its dispossessed Palestinian neighbors than South Africa was in the 1980s. Then, it was argued, South Africa was our strongest ally in the region, a bulwark in the war against communism, a crucial supplier of uranium and other minerals, a prosperous Western-style democracy, if not the only democracy on the continent. To bring down the South African apartheid regime, it was argued, would be to create chaos in southern Africa, unleash a bloodbath in which whites and blacks alike would suffer, and pave the way for a communist or dictatorial postcolonial regime. The divestment movement, a non-violent coalition of students and academics, union members and churches, came together in the spirit of the Civil Rights movement to challenge those self-serving assumptions. It changed the direction of US foreign policy, disgracing its support of a racist regime, and placed effective pressure on the apartheid regime to begin serious negotiations with the ANC. Through a combination of diplomacy and divestment, we did end apartheid, making way for a functioning multi-racial democracy that confronts its challenges, indeed, but has not dissolved into chaos or tyranny.

It is time for the United States to place a similar pressure on Israel. That Israel has been America’s beneficiary, unchallenged in its war crimes and in its acts of terror, uncontested for its racist civil constitution and illegal occupations, has not been to the United States’ advantage. On the contrary, such unquestioning support of Israel has fuelled the legitimate anger of the Islamic world, supplied the justification for terrorism, and continually tarnished the United States’ reputation among the democracies of the world. That the United States has stood so often alone in defending Israel before the court of world opinion in the United Nations is not a sign of its virtue, but of the obstinacy and arrogance of its stance.

But it is not for the sake of the reputation or advantage of the United States that you should take a new path in relation to Israel. It is in the name of justice. It is not just to support the territorial ambitions, realized settlement by settlement, of a Zionist minority in the region. It is not just to continue to supply Israel with the most advanced weapons and the most deadly arms in order that it may murder civilians, children and policemen. It is not just that we should support Israel with all our diplomatic force and financial aid, while leaving Israel’s victims to die slowly for lack of food, medicine, water and power. It is not just that we should sacrifice a dispossessed people for the security of a state that discriminates and expropriates, continually and violently ignores UN resolutions and international appeals, collectively punishes those whose right to resist occupation is recognized in international law. There is no road to peace through such injustice.

It may be that the compromise in the end will be the establishment and security of two separate states. Almost certainly, the only hope of a lasting solution is a single state in Israel/Palestine, committed to the civil and human rights of all peoples within its boundaries, irrespective of religion or ethnicity. That is, after all, the standard to which we hold all other states in the world, Israel alone excepted. But no solution at all will be possible until we hold Israel accountable for its criminal violence and its illegal acts, until we cease to supply it with the means to pursue a course of domination and expansion, with arms and warplanes, with finance and diplomatic support. It is time for constructive disengagement from Israel, financial, diplomatic, military. What worked in the case of South Africa, divestment and pressure, may finally work in the Middle East.

Without such justice, there will be no peace.

David Lloyd

University of Southern California

Los Angeles, January 1, 2009

1 point

History is always written by the winner, but the truth is always available to those who truly seek it, much like a person that seeks the truth about their passion - as in if you love a sports team or an artist or your job you will seek to know the facts about what you love --- so it is in everything else. I can't convince the Zionists that they are tools, much like the slaves couldn’t convince their masters that they should be treated equal. The Zionist and the Israeli must want be ready to accept the possibility that words that place any person as an inferior, these repeated words as a fact, as a mantra, as an oath are said to provide a vehicle to destruction. This is not as easy as it seems when you have Religion that preaches that you're superior. Real Power is to know and be willing to Love and be Loved without prejudice while knowing the awful Truth.

As what the Nazi use to say Propaganda is nothing but words repeated again and again.

2 points

and Israel is the one who really wants peace.

2 points

For Zionists to sleep at night they must repeat carefully chosen words -- words that provide comfortable sweet answers to the WHYsss, as in Why do we continue on killing Palestinian civilians, Why do we keep on creating generations of enemies.

The Zionist will kill your family and turn around and tell you that you started it. They will look at an innocent Child and say tough luck you started it.

You can't argue with facts, because to a Zionist Facts are just words in a book, and their book is always right. The same inalienable Rights the Southerners believed that they had to Own slaves and dispose of them like property. You see there was reason why the Spanish Inquisitors had a university education in law, in order to inflict death and torture you must be able to recite the right words that give you permission to proceed with taking life.

History is always written by the winner, but the truth is always available to those who

truly seek it, much like a person that seeks the truth about their passion, Zionists are not born they are fed.

As for the quick history lesson:

Russians and Europeans (Jews, which are known as ashkenazi, verus the 10% native Jews who lived in Palestine which were also known as Arab Jews) were promised Palestine, Jews can recite their holy book from here to the end of day those who came to settle in Palestine were Europeans, they were the outsiders, the invaders, the colonizer, irrespective, Palestine was also promised to the Arabs if they fought against Axis in WWI – see Lawrence of Arabia --- by the time WWII rolled in you had three Jewish underground terrorist organization working tirelessly to establish a Jewish Nation on a foreign land. Most of the Palestinians left because of acts that was perpetuated in Dier Yassin the first massacre committed by the Jews in Palestine.

Again, what happened has happened, a lot of bad things happen to good people in History, see the Blacks treatment in America, the American Indians, etc… but you know the main difference between our story and theirs?

Take a moment right now and re-read all the pro-Israelis post, you will find one thing in common, Lack of acknowledgment. Imagine the Killers want to do kill without any remorse or blame and they even want to be commended, they want to hear clapping and a standing ovation for killing Hamas babies, and Hamas children, and Hamas girls and Hamas boys, and all Palestinian men.

5 points

Actually, The truce broke between the two becuase Israel target killed hamas militiant, in which Hamas retaliated. But that is neither here or their. Israel never needs a reason to kill, arrest, hassle, torture, and abuse Palestinians, Israel has no repsect for any ARABS since they believe the land is given to them by God and everything on it can be taken.

The argument that hamas just need to stop seding rockets and everything would be fine, is flawed by the fact that Israel never stopped build settelments, never stopped annexing land, never stopped destroying homes, never stopped target killings, and at the same time never stoped talking about Peace.

How are you going to establish peace when Israel refuses to deal with the palestinians as an equal when there are roads that are dedicated for Israeli only, no arab can drive on, not even in nazi Germany did such racisim exist. Israel wants the repsect of a democracy when it acts like a dictator-theocracy.

The bombardment of Gaza is to weaken the will of all palastenians it tell them and the world that woman, children, and men can be killed at will - therfore force the palestinians into unjust terms for peace.

1 point

Let us call the European and Russian (Jew) domination of a brown-owned land a holy right.

This script sounds awfully familiar. Irrespective of how you believe Israel was formed,

In the present time Israel is a powerful and wealthy nation that picks on a small hapless people. Israel tirelessly works to dehumanize Palestinians, deprives them from the dignity to live any kind of normal life because Israel needs land since they are continuously growing by building settlements in “occupied” “disputed” territories and by “annexing” land that mysteriously “belongs to no people.”

Israeli’s want you to believe that they are the one who constantly live in fear, not the Palestinians that see with their own eyes the Israeli greed.

If you’re a Palestinian male you may be killed without question by an IDF, as if they have the souls of animals not humans. Now we witness the true face of Zionism culture, children, woman, and babies can be killed as long as the IDF is aiming at a terrorist target. Just add the word terrorist to any location and Death will be swallowed.

6 points

To the Zionist, it’s all about how they use and portray the appropriate language in order to justify mass killing of a people and still retain the unchallenged right to be the universal victim.

Palestinians, who will never accept to be re-named or erased by anybody including the world acclaimed universal victim. Zionists peddle their chosen words with the same precision and sophistication of their modern weapons. Right now the Israeli government wants to achieve victory, over a population that 80% of them survive on foreign food relief and 100% trapped in sliced up cantons, where they dig subterranean tunnels to connect with each other and get tools and weapons that are equivalent to a bow an arrow – compared to IDF weapons- with only one thought in mind, that is to survive.

Though, this is not really about killing, or explaining death by numbers, this is about permission to let a nation, a culture, a modern society, a people that are identified/protected in the civilized world as victims – The Israelis - to inflict suffering, pain, destruction and death on barbaric, primitive, inferior, possibly slave-like and definitely Terrorist people. The Israeli government is engaging in extending a platform of death to people who demand to be recognized as an equal in their own land. Israel is a leader for every Country in the world for every vile human being that aspires to abuse power by willful subjugation and humiliation of an entire people with the arrogance of polished words and the grace of super technology.

Dislodge has not yet created any debates.

About Me


I am probably a good person but I haven't taken the time to fill out my profile, so you'll never know!


Want an easy way to create new debates about cool web pages? Click Here