CreateDebate


Debate Info

1
4
They are mutually exclusive They are compatible
Debate Score:5
Arguments:4
Total Votes:6
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 They are mutually exclusive (1)
 
 They are compatible (3)

Debate Creator

Paul-ish(77) pic



Anarchism and Capitalism (See Anarcho-capitalism)

Are the two compatible?
Anarcho-capitalism (en.wikipedia.org)

They are mutually exclusive

Side Score: 1
VS.

They are compatible

Side Score: 4
1 point

1. Empirical Argument:

Capitalism is a societal order that currently exists in several countries.

Anarchism is a theoretical societal order that does not nor did not exist in any country that could also be described as capitalist at the same time.

2. Theoretical/Pricincipled Argument:

For Capitalism to function it requires the following concepts to be mutually agreed upon and accepted by ALL parties who wish to participate in capitalism:

a) concept of private property

b) common concept of capital or form of exchange (i.e. money)

Because those things have to be common among all capitalist participants there has to be a common authority to protect and enforce them which is antithesis of anarchism. Hence the two are incompatible.

3. Philosophical argument:

Just as in debate of weather the God exist or not. The side that purports to know the existence of God shoulders the responsibility for any evidence or proof, so is in this argument side that sais that Anarcho-capitalism CAN or DOES exist shoulders responsibility for proof. My side is content with the fact that historically the two forms of social organization have not coexisted together. So you can still believe in Anarcho-capitalism just like you can still believe in God.

4. Common sense argument

Just imagine doing business with an anarchist who thinks property is theft.

Side: They are mutually exclusive

Anarcho-capitalism isn't as evil as it sounds. Free markets and minds working together towards one common goal, progress. Government is the antithesis to progress.

Side: They are compatible
1 point

Anarchism is a political theory. Capitalism is an economic theory. The two can interact, but the one and the other are by no means contradictions. Most capitalists are inherently libertarians, though--not anarchists. They want to be able to take advantage of other's money but keep their own. In a state of anarchy, it's hard to protect what you have.

Side: They are compatible

Most anarchists are just extreme capitalists, so yah.

Side: They are compatible