CreateDebate


Debate Info

25
19
Yes No
Debate Score:44
Arguments:31
Total Votes:53
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Yes (12)
 
 No (16)

Debate Creator

DrawFour(2662) pic



Is it an insult to truthfully call someone a liar?

I've been told, even if a person is fat, it's still insulting to call them that (for some reason). So this got me to wondering about other potential insults.

Obviously this is refering to calling a person a liar, after you know they are lying for certain. 

Yes

Side Score: 25
VS.

No

Side Score: 19
2 points

You can try to insult someone, but if the person doesn't feel offended by the attempt, then its not an insult.

So, if a person feels insulted after you've called them liar, then yes, calling them a liar is an insult...truthful or not.

There is no objective way to define what is and what isn't an insult, since its all based on the feelings of the listener. One thing that's insulting to you, may not be insulting to me, etc, etc.

Side: Yes

Yes but if they do lie, you have the freedom of speech to call them that.

Side: Yes
vcaur143(8) Clarified
1 point

Well, based on the United States Constitution and many others, there IS freedom of speech ALTHOUGH it clearly states you can speak whatever you want BY NOT OFFENDING someone. Now, if the person you called a liar seems offended... then technically it is illegal, and considered an insult.

Side: Yes
2 points

There is no such thing as the right to not be offended. My free speech is my right as long as I dont abuse it.

Side: No
God_(507) Disputed
1 point

The right is the right to the freedom of speech not what you said. It doesn't matter whether it is insulting or not it is legal. The whole point of making that write was to ensure you had the right to speak your mind however if you say something that gets you in trouble you have to take personal responsibility for your actions.

Side: No
1 point

It might be a completely justified argument in calling someone truthfully a liar, but....it doesn't mean you have the right to do so.

Plus....why stoop so low? I'd just ignore them! ;)

Side: Yes
DrawFour(2662) Clarified
1 point

Well although that'd be another debate entirely, in the states you do have the right to call someone a lie, whether you know they are or not. However if it's said in a legal battle, and it's later discovered to be false, you could be charged with slander.

Side: Yes

It's stating a fact if it is true, not an insult. However it is different if you are calling someone fat because while that is also stating a fact it is a hurtful thing to say and being fat isn't immoral like how lying is. Also it is obvious if someone is fat where as if someone is a liar it isn't so there is no point in pointing out that someone is fat but there is if someone is lying.

Side: No
2 points

If it's simply a mentioning of a fact then it's not. It depends on the intention of the one calling out a liar. However, in the large majority of cases, there's an intention behind words.

If it's meant to hurt the liar, then it's an insult. If there's any kind of ill will aimed towards the person, then it's an insult. If, on the other hand, it's meant as a helpful reminder, then I don't see it as an insult. If am telling you that you are lying in order help you snap out of some bad mental habit, then it's a kind thing, not an insult.

The key here is the intention. If you call someone out of compassion for the person, it's not an insult. Otherwise, not so.

Side: No

Generally speaking, no- but it can be, depending on the circumstances.

For example, if you take affront to a little white lie on an issue that is just between you and the liar, and proceed to publically call them a liar in front of friends, family, etc- that is certainly insulting and inappropriate.

Side: No
1 point

No not necessarily, you can be just calling it the way it is.

However it can be said in an insulting manor even when stating fact.

So in all actuality this can go either way and is more of a gray area (non-specific) and should have been put as a perspectives debate.

Side: No
DrawFour(2662) Clarified
1 point

Truly everything comes down to perspective, doesn't it? I put it in this fashion to determine a hard answer.

Side: Yes

If a person is caught in lying, he should be address of his mistake.

Side: No