CreateDebate


Debate Info

4
1
Absolutely, they produced Osam No, they promote peace
Debate Score:5
Arguments:3
Total Votes:5
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Absolutely, they produced Osam (2)
 
 No, they promote peace (1)

Debate Creator

jnjcasper(24) pic



Saudi Arabia is the Most Severe Islamic Nation

Absolutely, they produced Osam

Side Score: 4
VS.

No, they promote peace

Side Score: 1

Read about the Saudis' dubious interfaith agenda at the UN here:

http://www.createdebate.com/argument/newarg/2826/4771

Side: Absolutely, they produced Osam
1 point

Saudi Arabia is currently hosting an international conference about inter-faith relations. They have even invited Israel to attend. A few years ago, Saudi Arabia brokered an Arab League deal to recognize Israel in exchange for Palestinian statehood. The country may have its flaws, but they are also active for peace in the world.

Side: No, they promote peace
2 points

They want a global law to punish blasphemy – a campaign championed by the 56-member Organization of Islamic Conference that puts the rights of religions ahead of individual liberties.

The lofty-sounding principle is, in fact, a cleverly coded way of granting religious leaders the right to criminalize speech and activities that they deem to insult religion. Instead of promoting harmony, however, this effort will exacerbate divisions and intensify religious repression.

Saudi Arabia is one of the world's worst abusers of religious freedom. The king couldn't hold this conference at home, where conservative clerics no doubt would purge the guest list of Jews from Israel, Baha'is, and Ahmadis.

Holding a session on advancing interfaith dialogue abroad is a pale substitute for hosting it in the kingdom, where the message of respect for freedom of religion and belief is most needed.

Dialogue is no substitute for compliance with universal human rights standards.

The UN and every world leader attending the special session should be demanding an end to severe violations of religious freedom in Saudi Arabia.

The Saudi government permits the public practice of only one interpretation of Islam. This forces the 2-to-3 million Christian, Hindu, Buddhist, and other expatriate workers there to leave their convictions at the border, since non-Muslim places of worship are prohibited, non-Muslim religious materials risk confiscation, and even private worship is affected by the strictures.

It also violates the rights of the large communities of Muslims who adhere to Islamic traditions other than the one deemed orthodox by Saudi clerics. In the past two years, dozens of Shiites have been detained for up to 30 days for holding small religious gatherings at home. One Ismaili, Hadi Al-Mutaif, is serving a life sentence after being condemned for apostasy in 1994 for a remark he made as a teenager that was deemed blasphemous. The alleged crime of apostasy, in fact, can be punished by death.

Side: Absolutely, they produced Osam