CreateDebate


Debate Info

2
7
Yes No
Debate Score:9
Arguments:6
Total Votes:9
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Yes (2)
 
 No (3)

Debate Creator

maccabaeus(231) pic



Are Judeo-Christian Laws against Rape a Good Thing?


The Right to Rape

Rape was common in Ancient Greece and seen by men as a 'right of domination.'

- Ancient Greece, History of Sex

Everyone agrees that even today rape remains a serious problem which must be prevented at any cost. However, the modern world's prosecution and incarceration of rapists is, in fact, a distinctly Judeo-Christian practice. Throughout the many centuries of Christianity, rape was seen as an outrage which was severely punished by the Church and State authorities. It never worked perfectly, of course, but the main ideal of catching and punishing those who sexualy assaulted others has enver waivered for nearly 2,000 yeas.

In stark contrast to this, many pre-Christian societies seldom, if ever, bothered to punish those who sexually assaulted others, whether they were male or female, slave or free. Greco-Roman civilization was no different and, as a consequence, the frequency of rape was much, much higher than it is today.

Indeed, it is only due to the Christian faith that the Roman Empire finally made rape a serious crime and began pnnishing those who committed it. Before that occurred however, the practice of violent sexual assault was viewed by Pagans as being within their 'rights' to do so, and that they did. A common method used by Greco-Roman males was to hide themselves near the wells used for drinking water. The rapists 'staked out water wells and then raped the women when they went to get water.' These weren't the only victims. One source notes that it was very common for Greco-Roman men 'to rape prostitutes, slaves, and their own wives.' Prostitutes, in particular, were vulnerable to attacks as 'Roman men were also allowed to beat and rape prostitutes who didn't perform the services they wanted for the prices that they wanted.'

Were Greece and Rome exceptional examples when it came to the acceptance and frequent occurence of violent rape? One should keep in mind that the ancient world also contained cultures where rape was fairly uncommon and highly frowned upon by most everyone. Some of them even had laws which prohibited and punished rape as a crime. The key to understanding why rape was such a common practice within the Greco-Roman Empire, is to understand their religious faith. In short, the Pagan Greeks, and soon after them the Romans, worshiped a certain set of gods who were known to be serial rapists, as well as violent murderers and sexual perverts. One source notes the major myths surrounding at least some of these Pagan deities:

Zeus, the god, was the master rapist who raped many women. He raped Leda in the form of a swan. He raped Danae disguised as the rain. He raped Alkmen disguised as her own husband. Zeus even raped other men, such as Ganymede.

- Ancient Greece, History of Sex

Thus, it should come as no surprise that rape was indeed tolerated and frequently practic

Yes

Side Score: 2
VS.

No

Side Score: 7
1 point

May God bless all females, who are made in the image of God and are all fellow sisters in Christ.

Side: Yes
Micmacmoc(2260) Disputed
2 points

You're sick! Are you trying to tell me that rapists shouldn't be punished?

That's ridiculous, they are a problem that defies the rights of the people who are assaulted in the process.

It is a violation of the fact that we are all born equal, we all have rights, and nothing can change that.

But you think it is fine?

Side: No
anachronist(889) Disputed
1 point

Read the description before you post an argument please. He's arguing that the only reason we aren't running around raping eachother is because of the morally superior Christians like himself.

Side: Yes
3 points

Christian laws require that the rape victim marry the rapist or be stoned. Oh, and they mostly prohibit the abortion of a foetus, which if continued can be harmful to the child and the victim.

Oh, and, rape was quite common in the old biblical days. Remember Lot and his daughters in that cave? That was divinely condoned, incestual rape. Rape happens in all cultures, religion does not stop it. In fact, more often than not, it encourages it. Because of the biblical laws about women being the property of their husbands, marital rape has been an accepted and legal practice for literally thousands of years. It is only since the secularisation of our law systems that old Christian traditions like wife beating and rape have been outlawed.

Don't get me started on the Catholic Church. Don't tell me religion prevents rape, it screens it and justifies it.

Have a read of 1Corinthians for some lovely bible verses promoting gender equality and discouraging from sexism. Insert sarcasm here.

Side: No

Barbaric Christian laws might have been a moral step above the Roman Empire's laws, but this hardly makes them ideal or model, as Anachronist pointed out. Additionally, I'm positive "rape is bad" is something we would have figured out on our own without Judeo-Christian influence. After all, we learned to almost universally condemn slavery despite Judeo-Christian support for it. We no longer murder children who disobey their parents, even though religious doctrine tells us so. This foolish notion that because some religions contained some elements of progressive thinking they are somehow responsible for our modern, civilized laws needs to go. "Dont kill people," for example, is just common sense; we don't need the Ten Commandments to tell us that, and we didn't base out murder laws off that Commandment.

Side: No