CreateDebate


Debate Info

1
3
Hamas attacked Israel. Over reaction by Israel.
Debate Score:4
Arguments:4
Total Votes:5
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Hamas attacked Israel. (1)
 
 Over reaction by Israel. (3)

Debate Creator

Norwich(1576) pic



Israel is taking the action necessary to protect its citizens from terrorist attacks.

The Hamas terrorist group invaded Israel killing some 1400 unarmed civilians, maiming 100s morre and taking non-combatant men women and children.
What did the Hamas Einsteinian terrorists think was going to happen?

Hamas attacked Israel.

Side Score: 1
VS.

Over reaction by Israel.

Side Score: 3
1 point

After the holocaust Israel was initially founded as a safe haven for Jews who were persecuted and/or butchered in their host countries.

When this sanctuary was threatened by the Hamas terrorists they had to react with a massive response.

The sanctimonious virtue signallers were nowhere to be seen or heard when 6 million, SIX MILLION Jews were being slaughtered in Germany's death camps.

Side: Hamas attacked Israel.
DelawareFire(2) Disputed
1 point

I don't see how the holocaust relates to the Hamas attacks. In fact, considering their past, it's should be even more sensical for the Israeli goverment to neither senselessly kill palestinian civilians nor opress them.

The Hamas attacking Israel simply doesn't warrant their killing of civillians, be it collateral or intentionally.

Side: Over reaction by Israel.
1 point

The anti-semitic rhetoric will have to be ignored by Israel until it has achieved its military objectives.

It is heartbreaking to see the scenes of civilian casualties just as it was during WW2.

Side: Over reaction by Israel.
1 point

Protection of their own citizens do not require attacks on palestinian civilians, no matter the situation. Instead of mass bombing areas, potentially killing hundreds of innocent civilians in pursuit of the terrorists, they should be thinking of other solutions.

Side: Over reaction by Israel.