CreateDebate


Debate Info

3
5
Help Hurt
Debate Score:8
Arguments:12
Total Votes:8
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Help (3)
 
 Hurt (4)

Debate Creator

flewk(1193) pic



Is this helping or hurting the site?

A user keeps resurrecting years-old debates, several on the same topic.

 

This pushes recent active debates down the list when using new activity sorting.

 

Is this helping or hurting the site?

Help

Side Score: 3
VS.

Hurt

Side Score: 5
1 point

if you are worried about the feed in the active category, but are looking for new debates maybe consider browsing the 'new' category. bring your own 'popularity' to those debates rather than following the trails of other people.

Side: Help
Foxglove(205) Clarified
1 point

That's just it though, following the trails of debates that are, as far as everyone else is concerned, long expired is superfluous; especially when many of these obsolete debates consist of past debaters who have since moved on from the site so are unlikely to even respond. There are active debates that, although not entirely fresh, are current enough that a number people are still engaging with them as opposed to one individual. It is spoiling it for those who may not fancy looking at the latest debates but may think one on the 'Active' category of greater interest in precluding them from finding those ones (that really are active).

Side: Help
Cartman(18192) Disputed
1 point

Debating involves discussing topics with other people. Other people don't have a way to find your response.

Side: Help
flewk(1193) Disputed
1 point

The bot resurrects several debates on the same topic. It does not really care about the content. It seems to be merely descending chronologically.

I am not sure how you think a human can bring anything to an active debate when the chat bot will just push that debate out of the active list.

Side: Hurt
Nomoturtle(858) Clarified
1 point

but the content of the posts doesn't seem to be written by a bot. look through PhxDemocrat's arguments. it isn't just spam, every post has an opinion, unless you can see these being repeated or plagiarised, i can't agree that it is just spam from a bot

Side: Help
2 points

This bot needs to be suspended. Its activity is making the site difficult to use. Any new activity is washed away within a matter of minutes.

Side: Hurt
1 point

Most of the users here are not going to revisit old debates, and as a result that puts dead weight on our feed. Just so you know, this was happening when I was here and much more active months ago.

Side: Hurt
flewk(1193) Clarified
1 point

Some guy resurrected 2000+ debates in a matter of a week?

Side: Help
Stickers(1037) Clarified
1 point

Nope. This is my first time back in a while, but we used to get debates over this topic. It was probably a few dozen a week that would resurface, and we'd have a round of who done it, but I didn't realize that it went this far.

Side: Help

It really annoys me when people dispute arguments that I wrote a year or two years ago. Leave the past in the past. Dredging up old debates is pointless. They are done and dusted so leave them in the past.

Side: Hurt