CreateDebate


Debate Info

12
13
Red Devils are the best Blancos are the greatest
Debate Score:25
Arguments:15
Total Votes:29
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Red Devils are the best (9)
 
 Blancos are the greatest (6)

Debate Creator

ololo32(6) pic



Manchester United vs Real Madrid

Two of the most well-known footbal teams in the world. Let's see who are really better!

Red Devils are the best

Side Score: 12
VS.

Blancos are the greatest

Side Score: 13

Speaking as a Man United fan... WOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!! YEEEEEEAAAAAAHHHHHHH!!!!!! UNITED UNITED UNITED! BEST IN THE WORLD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Speaking objectively... Ronaldo Madrid have the edge. The current united team is way below the standard of previous teams under Fergie. Our midfield is as weak as spring water, its sluggish and lacks creativity. I heard a rumour that we were gonna sign Modric for 50 million. I doubt it, but it would be great if we could. The defense is ok, but Ferdinand is getting old, we need a replacement better than Evans for him. Up front we're ok, Rooney is a beast and Welbeck is making a name for himself. We still have Chicharito, Berbatov AND Owen in support. Dodgy De Gea isn't Fergie's best signing, but Lindergaard is doing a decent job in goal.

But Ronaldo Madrid just have quality everywhere we don't. First of all: Ronaldo. I despise the guy, but he's so damn good. I think I'm one of the few who believe he's a better player than Messi. He's scored something like 76 in 65 games, in other words; beastly. Ozil, Sahin and Alonso in midfield are miles ahead of ours. They have 2 amazing full backs and the best keeper in the world. Mourinho is a cynical douche, but he kept Fergie on his toes in the prem. So I think they are a better team at the moment.

But I am a United fan, so I must stay on this side.

Side: Red Devils are the best
1 point

I'm a fan of Manchester United, soon, I now will write as a neutral person. If we compare these two clubs I read that they both have just a rich history. Real Madrid has always been a team of stars, but also in Manchester are the stars, which are "White" bought for big money, now I was referring to s top player according to FIFA, Cristiano Ronaldo 2008. If we compare these clubs over the past 5 let we can conclude that Real Madrid has made nothing in particular, rather than ME. A if you look at the fact.

Greatnes is the sum total of a club’s football and other activities. Real may have won countless trophies, but ones who think they did by only fair means are kidding themselves. Real aren’t even the “greatest” team in Spain, let alone the world.

The cruelties mounted by Franco against a club like Barcelona during his reign are proof that Madird never won a single trophy in the pre-80′s era through fair means. Heck, even Stefano was blackmailed into joining Madrid by Franco’s regimen, whereas his intended destination was Barcelona.

By contrast, United have been victims of tragedies like the WWII bombings on Old Trafford (due to which the club had to rent neighbours, City’s, ground for the better part of a decade), the Munich air disaster, where the club not only lost it’s finest generation of players, most of them younger than 25, but also all the hardwork put in by the great Sir Matt during the 40s and 50s. The fact that United rebuilt within the short span of a decade to return to European supremacy is a credit to the spirit of the club. Even as early as the first decade of the 1900s United, then Newton Heath, faught banksupcy and returned in the famous red and white of United to go on and win the first FA Cup ever.

The latest tragedy to have befallen on the great club, codename: Glazer, is one which’s effects you almost never see in the football because of the great Sir Alex. Any other manager would never have seen 3 back to back league titles, a Champions League crown, and countless other domestic titles in a period where the club has been drained of all it’s wealth by a greedy bunch with no heart.

Inspite of not reinvesting a majority of the 80 million pounds gained by selling the best player in the world (who was literally made at Carrington) United managed to run the free spending Chelsea close.

The fact of the matter is, Madrid will always be known as the playground of superstars, but home is where the heart is, and Madrid will never compare to this:

United, home to- Ronaldo, Beckham, Giggs, Scholes, Best, Charlton, Meredith, et al.

Madrid, home to- err… Raul?!

Side: Red Devils are the best
1 point

First of all, it is very debatable topic.

Many support Manchester United and many support Real Madrid... Personally, I support and I love Chelsea.

Now I see good opportunity to share my own ideas with people even through the Internet. I really love football. From the beginning of my childhood i have watched many football matches both of MU and Real Madrid. I think, I'm very happy person who have visited Old Trafford stadium, there i felt unbelievable feelings because funs who sang MU's anthem was very beautiful and so loudly it even stun me.

I think, it will not be correct to compare them, because both of clubs have own privileges which distinguish them from each other. It would be better, if people would start to compare whole league of England and Spain. Nowadays Barcelona is the best football team in the world but this particular club play in Spanish championship were competitiveness is weaker that English Premier league. Moreover, playing in England more difficult than in Spain because all English clubs need more resources because they can play even than 40 games during the one calendar year. It is well known fact that players in England take more injures for that reason participating in the Champions League at the same time is very big issue..

Side: Red Devils are the best
1 point

Man. United in my blood, because no rich transfers, they develop their own. Coaches do not change anytime. It is really proud football club, where money does not solve the problems.

Side: Red Devils are the best
1 point

This 2 teams are awful ! They survive because of MONEY !! For example, if one of them will have a situation like Valencia C.F. (AMUNT !) they would disappear it football world. And do not try to say that MU and Real have a great history. It is all money. However, I think that MU is better than Real, because they passed the problem after the air crash.

Side: Red Devils are the best
1 point

according to current successes united leads.hell!! they have been to champions league finals three times in four years....whr is madrid????!!!!

Side: Red Devils are the best
1 point

Manchester Utd continue to defy the odds and achieve highly whilst only spending 20-30 mil a year while madrid go through managers and players like its going out of fashion

Side: Red Devils are the best
1 point

man u as they are so pro and they are english and i like the premier league

Side: Red Devils are the best
3 points

Real Madrid, statistically is the stronger side. 31 league titles, 18 Copa del Reys, and 9 Champion Leagues are way more than United.

Side: Blancos are the greatest
janth22(10) Disputed
1 point

They are in a different league, it would make more sense to compare champions leagues of RECENT where MUFC have been stronger

Side: Red Devils are the best
2 points

For me, Real Madrid is better, not only because of my passion of white colour of their jerseys. But, rather due their rich historical achievements in almost all areas of footbal.

Side: Blancos are the greatest
2 points

In my comprehension there is no such think as "better".. Because, actually there is no objectives for it. For instance we can take number of trophies, but there is really difference in league competitiveness. Thus, Real could gain more trophies than ManU, accordingly real is better.

Also, there can be take into account head-to-head matches, where real is leading. However, it can be tricky, because as it was in last head-to-head match between those teams, after winning the first game comfortably, real went to Manchester without a huge desire to crush home team. Therefore, statistically, ManU came close to Real. Next, meeting in common tournament is so complicated task.. Last time, they meet almost 10 years ago.. Plus this year they won't play certainly!

Lastly, there is fans! A lot of fans, everywhere.. No fan of Real probably will agree that Blancos is worse than Red Devils vise verse.. Even the fact that it's difficult to compare two of this particular teams, I started to believe that Real has more chance to be named better team rather than Manchester..

Side: Blancos are the greatest
2 points

i hate both of these teams:( go liverpool and barcelona! id have to say i hate manU more. so blancosssssss

Side: Blancos are the greatest
2 points

If you look at it in terms of recent success, then Utd are better, but Real have still got a more enviable record in Europe (as do a number of clubs). Really, both teams pale before Barcelona.

Side: Blancos are the greatest
2 points

Thank you for this good debate argument.

I think that Real Madrid is the best because Manchester united doesn't have good defense and Real Madrid has a really good attack.

Also in many electronic games, most people choose Real Madrid because they have a really good stamina. Also they attack and defense well so they don't loose many times like the Manchester United.

Side: Blancos are the greatest