CreateDebate


Debate Info

4
4
Should not be Criticized Should be Criticized
Debate Score:8
Arguments:11
Total Votes:8
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Should not be Criticized (4)
 
 Should be Criticized (4)

Debate Creator

wassup(5) pic



Should Suicide be Criticized

 Suicide is something very odd. It's about taking away one's life away by oneself. Someone is dead but no one is blamed for the death(unless another person made him/her to do so). In history, it was even a way to prove your innocence or to show your loyalty. But nowadays, as you can see in the phrase "COMMIT a suicide", it is considered a crime, something to be condemned. I also agree that it is not something good to do, but does that mean that committing a suicide should be criticized BY OTHERS? I don't think so
 First of all, its your life. Murder is a serious crime because you're taking away someone else's life, and you don't have the authority to do it. But don't you have the power to control yours? If you have a religion, then i guess your life is not yours but god(s)'s, but let's concentrate on this topic first. If someone has attempted a suicide, that person was probably in a horrible situation. Nobody is going to live his/her life for him/her. Nobody is going to take the pain. Still they blame him/her. Isn't there something wrong about this? I don't believe that others have the right to criticize the person.
 Also, suicide does not cause real harm to anybody else. Well you may say it give mental damage to people around the person. Can that really be a reason to blame the guy who committed a suicide? There is something called psychological injury in the law(;meaning psychological or psychiatric conditions associated with an event that leads, or may lead, to a lawsuit in tort action or other legal-related claims), but suicide doesn't fit in this domain in most of the countries. Every event causes an emotional change in everybody. The only difference is how and how much. You can't blame the self-killing guy to consider everybody else's feelings.
 At last, people say that criticizing suicide is a way to keep the society to respect life. I totally think this is wrong. The instinct to live is in your DNA. Do you know why so many people fail to commit a suicide? It's because most people get scared at the last moment. That is also the reason why most suicides are accidental. Their emotion at that time was too much for them to handle, that it overcame their inborn fear of death. The basis of respect for life doesn't come from social things, in comes from your natural fear of death. Furthermore, is keeping someone alive whose life is so horrible that he/she tried to terminate it really respecting life? It's something to think about.
 To sum up, you have the authority to control your life, you don't hurt anyone, and criticizing suicide does not have a lot to do with respect for life. So even though I think committing a suicide is a horrible thing, I don't think those who killed themselves does not deserve to be criticized.

Should not be Criticized

Side Score: 4
VS.

Should be Criticized

Side Score: 4
1 point

altogether ending semicolon bending

Side: Should not be Criticized
1 point

I could not criticize anybody who was in constant chronic pain, with no cure in sight, for undergoing euthanasia.

I also feel it should be legal in the USA.

God Bless Doc Kevorkian!

Side: Should not be Criticized
Saintnow(3684) Clarified
1 point

Do you remember Dr Krevorkian? I was in Pontiac within a couple hundred yards of Osteopathic Hospital where he was dropping off bodies after he offed the people who asked him to help them "out". Some of the people he offed were in better condition than some people I was friends with at the time, wheelchair bound and in constant pain facing death at young ages. The problem with allowing euthanasia is that family members and society sooner or later will force in on handicapped people who don't really want it. The lines become blurred........but hey, if God does not care, why not just go out as quickly and painlessly as possible? It's always wrong, suicide is murder of yourself. There is no such thing as good death, euthanasia is murder and if the one being put to death is agreeing to it, it's conspiracy to murder.

An old friend of mine, one of my few best friends, was told around nine months ago that he had stage four cancer which was causing tumors in his connective tissues all over his body. Because he was 80 yrs old, he decided not to take any treatments for it. He got around well and was in little or no pain up until the last month of the six he lived before succumbing. The tumors were in his lungs also, causing difficulty breathing and great difficulty in expelling fluids which built up from leaking around the tumors. I visited with him a day or two before the last day he was really communicating with people. His mind remained sharp, and he never lost sight of the hope he had in knowing he was going to be with the Lord in heaven.

He never complained. He only asked to set a good example of hope and confidence in his Savior, and he prayed that others would come to know the Savior due to the influence of the example he was setting. He considered it an honor to be afflicted with this very rare form of cancer, a 1 in 5000 case and he only wanted to show the grace of God which gives us power to endure suffering as Jesus suffered for us.

Euthanasia is wrong, suicide is always selfish and wrong.

Side: Should not be Criticized
1 point

Fuck you and your self righteous judge mental shit. You have no right encouraging people to suffer long term. That makes you Christians judge mental cruel fucks.

Side: Should be Criticized
1 point

One thing I cannot stand is victim blaming.

Side: Should not be Criticized
1 point

Yes, but not because I'm anti-suicide, because I believe in free expression and the freedom for anything and everything to be criticized. Heck, I support euthanasia in cases of terminal illnesses and suffering. And I really don't even mind if some random individual is just tired of this world and wants to leave. Fine. But to expect those still opting to live to say nothing to those who attempted or are planning suicide is folly. We all get to have our say. In fact we'd be irresponsible to hide what we truly think and feel about it.

Side: Should be Criticized
Bohemian(3860) Disputed
1 point

There is an old adage, "Just because you can do something, doesn't mean you should."

Whether an individual ought to have the right to express their opinions, of course they should, but that is different question entirely from whether they ought to exercise that right at any and all opportunities. The answer to which is obviously, no.

Should people have the right to criticize suicide? Absolutely. Should they exercise that right? No, no they should not.

Side: Should not be Criticized