CreateDebate


Debate Info

21
7
For Against
Debate Score:28
Arguments:20
Total Votes:31
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 For (13)
 
 Against (7)

Debate Creator

gumyr(61) pic



Should pregnant girls continue the education?

Teenage pregnancy is seen as a major social problem in many countries. As many of these unmarried mothers are 16 or younger and in full-time education, this raises the question about whether they should continue in school or be made to leave. If they should remain in education, should schools and education authorities have to pay for special facilities to support them, including crèches to provide childcare while they are in class, etc.?

For

Side Score: 21
VS.

Against

Side Score: 7
3 points

Pregnant women of all ages often carry on working until just a few weeks before they give birth, and many return to some sort of work after only a brief period of maternity leave. In olden times and in peasant societies today, women would be expected to carry on working in the fields with a baby strapped to them. There doesn’t seem to be anything so different about being at school that rules out carrying on with as much of your previous life as possible once you have become pregnant. Indeed, children under 16 legally have to be full-time education in many countries, so there should be an expectation that very young mothers do stay in the classroom.

Side: For
1 point

JUST STOP. I am so sick and tired of you, why aren't you satisfied debating with someone? If you want to put down extensive opinions like this, write an op-ed piece for the Times, or start a column in your local paper, just leave us the FUCK alone.

Side: Against
TheThinker(1688) Disputed
1 point

It is not wrong for him to continue writing comments on his own debate. Or any debate. Just leave him be. You know? :)

Side: For
2 points

We should not be judgemental towards young mothers; it would be unfair to punish them in order to send a message to others. Indeed, it is legal in many countries to get married at 16 and so quite possible for a married student to become pregnant while still in high school. If anything, having young mothers with babies in school is more likely to put other students off irresponsible sexual activity, as the natural consequences of this will be brought home to them. Seeing how demanding a young baby can be and how tired the mother gets is also likely to ensure other students avoid unwanted pregnancies.

Side: For
2 points

Mothers in education are not often going to bring babies into the classroom; they will be in crèche facilities or being cared for by relatives during the school day. In fact pregnant students and young mothers are likely to become more focused in class, motivated to continue their studies and to succeed because it is not just their own future that they are thinking about anymore. Their presence may also help others reflect on the value of an education and so contribute to a better learning atmosphere.

Side: For
2 points

Most women in most societies have to work while caring for babies. Typically extended families help with childcare and this continues today with grandmothers often looking after baby in the day so that young mothers can continue to study. Providing baby has good quality contact with the mother every day and knows it is loved, there is no evidence that a few hours regular absence poses any harm. Where such family help is not possible, schools should be willing to support students with crèche facilities to enable them to remain in education.

Side: For
2 points

If we throw pregnant girls out of school we cut them off from all their friends, socially isolating them at a vulnerable time in their lives. This is deeply unfair and likely to alienate all the children involved from authority. Pregnant girls will be going through all kinds of changes that will accelerate further after birth; at such times they need to know that their friends still care for them and accept them.

Side: For
2 points

Education is essential in modern society to increase chances of stability. Objectively, in my opinion it shouldn't be essential and if you have natural talent or get lucky, by all means you should be able to be successful that way. But with or without a child, education is now an important factor in success. Having a child, even though it's much harder to do both, doesn't change that fact.

Side: For
2 points

Of course they should. Why have them laying around doing nothing surviving off food stamps?

Side: For
1 point

Young mothers need a chance to gain qualifications that will let them earn money to support their child in the future. Cutting these girls off from education denies them this opportunity and makes it likely that the state will need to support their family for many years to come. And isn’t there a fairness issue here? Why should expectant girls be excluded from school but not the boys who got them pregnant?

Side: For

Of course. Nobody can't deny other people's want to educate and better themselves. I mean isn't deny that "girl's" education hypocritical becuase it was the LACK of education that brought her to the state of pregnancy. I kinda find that hypocrisy funny.

Side: For
1 point

Yes. Unless the ultrasound or some other medical reason prevents it, they should absolutely continue their education. They are obviously not very smart to start with since they got pregnant, so they need to get smarter. It would be crazy to kick them out of school.

Supporting Evidence: www.axessultrasound.com (www.axessultrasound.com)
Side: For
1 point

Yes, if we don't give them education, they will be more of a liability than an asset to society. We want them to be able to take care of themselves and their baby, so that we don't have to be burdened paying them welfare checks.

Side: For
1 point

Society should discourage unmarried teenagers from the sexual activity that can lead to pregnancy, so we should regard students who become pregnant as bad role models for other students. It is therefore reasonable to require pregnant students to leave the school when their condition becomes known.

Side: Against
1 point

If schools are required to keep teaching students who become pregnant and give birth, this will be very expensive. Young mothers will at the least need a special room to feed and change a baby in, and could demand that the school board fund childcare facilities while they are in the classroom. These additional costs will impact on the education of all other students, which is unreasonable. Nor should taxpayers be asked to fund an irresponsible girl who chose to become pregnant.

Side: Against
1 point

Having young mothers in school will be disruptive for other students’ education. Many students find it hard to concentrate at the best of times, so a crying baby or mobile toddler in the classroom will greatly distract them from their studies. And once a girl becomes pregnant it is likely that she will miss a lot of lessons for sickness, medical appointments, etc., taking up unfair amounts of a teacher’s time in trying to catch up when she does reappear in the classroom.

Side: Against
1 point

The first two years of a baby’s life are a precious time for both mother and child, when they form a lifelong bond. No one else can care for a child like its own mother, and so she should be at home full time with her baby, learning to look after him or her, not away struggling to keep her education going.

Side: Against
1 point

Mothers need to be part of a wider social support group, meeting other mothers of all ages in baby groups and having their children playing together as they grow. If we keep young mothers in education we deny them this network of support, with its opportunities to share concerns, hopes and fears with others who understand their situation.

Side: Against
0 points

Pregnancy and motherhood are huge life changes for any woman. Teenage mothers-to-be will not be able to study effectively any more, and once the baby is born they will be too busy looking after it to attend school. Even if they have help with child care during the day, broken nights mean that they will not be in a position to concentrate in class, undertake homework assignments or revise for exams.

Side: Against
TheThinker(1688) Disputed
1 point

I understand your comment but not as answer to your debate. Yes it is difficult to educate yourself when you do have a child but that doesn't mean that the woman should stop her education. For this reason, downvote.

Side: For