CreateDebate


Debate Info

Debate Score:7
Arguments:6
Total Votes:7
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Should prisoners be able to vote? (6)

Debate Creator

danniit97(10) pic



Should prisoners be able to vote?

Personally I am for this. Although everyone will argue with me saying they had their rights abolished from them after committing a crime, I still believe politics is open to absolutely everyone as a democratic society - surely taking away this free will makes our society one which is a dictatorship? 
Add New Argument
2 points

Politics is not open to everyone. Children are not allowed to vote, either are non citizens and the mentally incompetent. The bigger question is should we allow felons to vote AFTER they get out of prison. I think you will be very hard pressed to find people who think prisoners serving time should vote before they are released.

shaash(434) Disputed
1 point

What if there is a new law that bans the practice of a religion, and you end up in jail. You think it is unjust; that the system is rigged. Not letting criminals vote will create corruption.. The mentally incompetent shouldn't be allowed to vote, but criminals should.

1 point

Drug offenders are not criminals. Until this understood. Yes. the only criminals who should have felonies and lose their rights are violent people.

You are correct in your prediction that most people would, quite rightly, argue that the convicted criminal should automatically lose all liberties and rights when they commit crimes against society. Once they have paid for their crime they could apply for inclusion back onto the electorate register. A panel of judges made up from a cross section of society could decide whether or not to grant permission for the applicant to participate in the democratic process. Many factors would influence the decision including the nature of the crime and the frequency of the ex-convict's offences. For instance, a career sex offender or violent criminal should never be allowed to take part in the process of electing a government.

1 point

yes, if they are eligible. Meaning age appropriate. They are still citizens. The reason that children are not aloud to vote is because they are not mature enough. Just because someone is held as prisoner does not mean that they can't support the vote of one.

Absolutely. If you are a US citizen you should be allowed to vote. Period. End of story. If i ever got put in prison for a crime that was up for debate, for instance pot legalization, i would want a say. If im in jail for possessing weed and theres a guy running to legalize it then i should get to vote for him.