Hey you and bradford need to get this straightened out in my other debate: http://www.createdebate.com/debate/show/
"There is no better way to control yourself in a game than with a mouse and keyboard."
I dunno, I kinda like game controllers, especially since they vibrates and seem much more 'natural' or intuitive, increasing the immersiveness of the game.
I can't imagine playing Tekken on a keyboard for example, that would be awful.
You know what I mean :p
For me there's a big difference in my gaming experience between playing a vampire and playing a cop.
The former is pure fantasy and the latter is more contemporary, or 'characteristic of the present'. Same with Grand Theft. Unless you have a better word for me.
However, if you're talking about a game involving mythology or with highly fictionalized main characters that may have super-human abilities, then I guess that could be categorized as fantasy.
Anyway, I'm not too concerned about hard-coded definitions, so you can place your coolest games in whichever column you feel is more appropriate.
Just make sure you list 'em all, in separate arguments if you like for tag ratings.