CreateDebate


Debate Info

Debate Score:27
Arguments:25
Total Votes:29
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Moment of Decision 1776 (24)

Debate Creator

coachkevinhe(33) pic



Moment of Decision 1776

Should we remain loyal to the King, fight for independence, build a bridge, or fight for our rights as Englishman?
Add New Argument
1 point

option 3

My fellow English men and colonist, as men of this new world we must rise against the tyranny that has been plaguing this new world. we where given this land by our great king, yet are Being taxed by a form of govt that dose not let us have our say against the taxes bestowed on us, we must fight for our right to the land that was given to us by our great king and must ask him to take back the power of this great land and let us import our own choices of spices and goods, we where given the right by the king not Parliament so we should rise against Parliament with out war and take back our rights given to us by our English king. If you love you family, county, and freedom then you should come with this movement for freedom from Parliament

2 points

concerned citizen Micheal Smithson: do you believe that measures can be made to gain your freedoms without inciting violence?

casey_suli(8) Disputed
1 point

this has been stated already there is no need for violence, just freedom

2 points

Silas Brattle concerned citizen: Why would anyone want to be part of a nation that doesn't give rights to its people?

casey_suli(8) Disputed
1 point

we where given the right by our king and we should ask him to stand up for us against parlment

A-aron(13) Disputed
1 point

Silas Brattle concerned citizen: For as long as we've been in this new world, why can't we protect ourselves?

casey_suli(8) Disputed
1 point

if we protect our self with viloence we will not prosper we must push and fight with out violence

1 point

george lee- Why wouldn't you want to stay where you are free-Jayden F

casey_suli(8) Disputed
1 point

that why we must work for are freedom with no harm to us we are to venerable

1 point

Rebel and be free. Opt~4

-They have murdered our fathers and brothers, burned our homes and stole our property.

-The brave souls who came to find the religious freedom and economic opportunity they were denied in England

- Britain has not protected our interests, but its own

-We don’t need Britain help any more because we're growing.

-Our trade would expand to a greater way.

-Locke mentioned a social contract but he believed the government shouldn’t raise taxes or lay claim without agreement.

-Many people like locke were upset about the laws that were upset about laws that were passed without their consent.

-”The state of nature has a law of nature to govern it, which obliges every one: and reason, which is that law, teaches all mankind that all being equal and independent no one ought to harm another in his life, health, liberty, or possessions.”- Locke

-Locke believed that if the government broke the social contract, the people could turn on the government.

ggalbert(5) Disputed
1 point

concerned citizen Micheal Smithson: if you decide to rebel against the crown, what will you do next

casey_suli(8) Disputed
1 point

there is no need to turn against the crown because we should never turn arms on are fellow Englishmen

1 point

Silas Brattle concerned citizen: Even if this action is successful, what do we do if Britain eventually retaliate with allies from other countries?

casey_suli(8) Disputed
1 point

then it is up to the king to take up his duty and right to protect us against ternary

1 point

Concerned citizen Charles St. James: If I help towards fighting for independence from Britain, would that allow me to trade to any country I wish to if we win our independence?

1 point

option 2: we want to make an American Parliament and be under rule by the country of great Britain, have a taxation with representation

Supporting Evidence: option 2 (docs.google.com)
1 point

Silas Brattle concerned citizen: Can we not come together on two separate nations without violence?

garylott2(5) Clarified
1 point

there is really no way to split apart from the country that gave us the chance to make this land ours and spread the word of the king, it would also create a lot of tension because the mother country would think we would rise above great Britain and take over their country. so no their is no possible way to separate from the mother country and not cause violence

A-aron(13) Disputed
1 point

George Lee- Why did you treat us the way you did?-Jayden F

1 point

Option 1

The rebels In the colonies will be sorely mistaken if they believe that separating from Britain is the right plan. Staying loyal to the king is the best plan that we have in the colonies. Britain has the largest navy and arsenal to fight with. Britain gives us land and money to support us and leaving would show how ungrateful the colonies would be. If we leave Britain we lose major economic benefits and protection that we have been guaranteed by the king and Britain.

The taxes that we pay in Britain to finance this protection and self government are much lower that the people in Britain pay. This strong military and fighting force can be turned on us as quickly as it can help us if we decide that we want to leave Britain. As well as material benefits we have a religious obligation to stay loyal. It is not right to rebel against the mother country.

Our greatest act of patriotism, unlike the rebels who call themselves patriots, is to stay loyal to our king and accept the help and protection that he gives us. This system has been in place for many years before us and should not be thrown away just like this. If the rebels do succeed, we will be left in a mess of argument, disorder, and tyranny. The kings and parliaments control over the colonies keeps them unified and in peace.

Supporting Evidence: powerpoint (docs.google.com)
ggalbert(5) Disputed
1 point

concerned citizen Micheal Smithson: if the crown wants to protect us, why did they make a proclamation line

1 point

Concerned citizen Charles St. James: I am heavily in debt with British merchants and they are not allowing me to repay our debt so therefore I can not make profit, so by siding with the king, will they help me resolve this problem and loose some of my debt or help me make fair trades to make profit.

A-aron(13) Disputed
1 point

Silas Brattle concerned citizen: Do we not have the right as people to build a civilization and create our own government?

A-aron(13) Disputed
1 point

George Lee- You think yall are being treated well?-Jayden F

0 points

concerned citizen Micheal Smithson: do you feel as if the British regulars are treating you well