CreateDebate


Debate Info

4
11
Yes, they are detrimental No, they are not detrimental
Debate Score:15
Arguments:14
Total Votes:15
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Yes, they are detrimental (4)
 
 No, they are not detrimental (9)

Debate Creator

thaminator(9) pic



Beauty pageants for children are detrimental

Children often participate in beauty pageants due to the wishes of their parents who tend to dress them up in certain costumes and these children are paraded before a mass audience which consists of mostly adults, some of whom might be paedophiles.

Yes, they are detrimental

Side Score: 4
VS.

No, they are not detrimental

Side Score: 11
1 point

Children are noisy and smelly, and they are most certainly not beautiful --- so why inflate their ego?

Side: Yes, they are detrimental
andrefoo(5) Clarified
1 point

why would you say that they are smelly? they might not be smelly because smelly is subjective...

Side: Yes, they are detrimental
1 point

Everyone is born smelly --- that's what showers are for! Surely you want your pageant participants to be pleasant on the nose!!!!

Side: Yes, they are detrimental
andrefoo(5) Disputed
1 point

its like saying everyone is greedy because they need to eat

Side: No, they are not detrimental
thaminator(9) Disputed
1 point

I said that everyone is born smelly --- a MEDICAL fact, but it is not the same as what you IMPLIED about me saying that everyone is born greedy, which is VALUE JUDGMENT..... HA!

Side: Yes, they are detrimental
1 point

Oh sure, as if kids don't have enough activities to keep them from developing any useful skills, let's go ahead and teach them that they are only valuable if they are young and cute, and heap on a whole mess of stress while we are at it. No problems there.

Side: Yes, they are detrimental
2 points

I say no, but I also thing yes. Because watching "Toddlers and Tiaras" has showed me that children participating in "glitzy" pageants are bratty and their parents are moronic, hypocritical, bitches/bastards. But if you watch the children in natural pageants in which they wear the dress, maybe do their hair a little fancier than normal, but don't lather themselves in make-up and stuff, it really is a fun way to express themselves, also being showed off and winning a crown here and their really does boost their self esteems! I love watching those little girls have fun dancing around the stage looking all happy, normal, and NATURAL. One of the best things is their pretty smiles and photogenic faces. Plus, their parents aren't so stupid and stuck-up !

Side: No, they are not detrimental
2 points

If Kids want to take part I dont think there's a problem it's just when they are unwilling participants that I think it is detrimental

Side: No, they are not detrimental
1 point

eeeew.... why do you even want to smell them... sometimes, being too close for comfort is really to be too close...

Side: No, they are not detrimental
1 point

These kids will eventually grow up to be our future models and actors so let's pump our industry and economy early!

Side: No, they are not detrimental

No, I think beauty pageants help children to suck it up and grow a pair. There are going to be people judging them unfairly, based upon something superficial and shallow, most of their lives. By getting an early start, they get an edge/

Side: No, they are not detrimental
1 point

How about cheerleading?

They are also put in small costumes and it's probably the perverts fantasy land.

Basketball, badminton .. you name a sport for women were they aren't wearing tiny clothes.

Are all those sports detrminetal for children? Should we ban them to save them from the horror of being looked at by people?

To compete on who is looking better, is not worse for a kid than compete who's doing better in fx. sports or musical competitions.

Side: No, they are not detrimental

As long as the daughter wants to enter a Little Miss Sunshine beauty pageant and she is happy to be a contestant, then the beauty pageant would not be detrimental.

Side: No, they are not detrimental