Is there anything wrong with doing the right thing for the wrong reason?
Right Action. Wrong Intentions. Anything wrong with that?
-Apollo
Yes
Side Score: 1
|
No
Side Score: 2
|
|
|
|
1
point
|
I wouldn't argue that it's morally wrong or "wrong" in the sense that it invalidates whatever was done "right". The example that comes to mind for me, is a guy who encourages a girl he likes to break up with an abusive partner. It's beneficial for someone to leave an abusive relationship, but encouraging someone to leave so they might date you is a manipulative thing to do. I suppose the question must be asked, what are right and wrong reasons to do things? Those are terms made up by us. I guess the "right" and "wrong" thing to do depends on what you're trying to achieve. Side: Neither
|