CreateDebate


Debate Info

8
7

Joe Donnelly (D)


Luke Puckett (R)

Debate Score:15
Arguments:7
Total Votes:16
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 
Joe Donnelly (D)
(4)
 
 
Luke Puckett (R)
(3)

Debate Creator

CreateDebate(732) pic



Who should I vote for in the 2008 Indiana 2nd District House of Representatives Race?


Joe Donnelly (D)

Side Score: 8
VS.


Luke Puckett (R)

Side Score: 7
3 points

Last week, Donnelly led a delegation with Congressmen Donald Cazayoux (D-LA), Steve King (R-IA) and John McHugh (R-NY) into Iraq and Afghanistan to visit US troops and assess the situation between he American military and Iraqi forces. During this time of uncertainty on the hill regarding America's position in Iraq, Donnelly felt that showing encouragement and support for the ilitary overseas would help boost morale and ease diplomatic tensions.

Donnelly:"My first stop was in Iraq, which I found to be significantly more stable since my trip this past December. This was evident to me throughout my travels around the country, and especially in Fallujah. The improvements will, hopefully, allow us to withdraw additional troops in the next few months, and we will continue to cede control of more territory to the Iraqis, allowing our soldiers to head home while leaving behind a secure Iraq."

After visiting the Middle East, he stopped in Georgia which is currently undergoing hostilities with aggressive Russia to show American support for the political ally.

Donnelly expressed his concern for the democratic country and wanted to express his sentiments of good will.

After Obama's controversial trek across Europe to express his sentiments of future peace between America and other world powers, is Donnelly's trip to visit troops and express support overseas a "publicity run" as Obama's was called, or is the tactic of speaking face-to-face with our allies becoming a diplomatic trend?

Supporting Evidence: Donnelly goes to Iraq and Georgia (donnelly.house.gov)
Side: Joe Donnelly
1 point

Last month, Donnelly sponsored a bill which amended the Internal Revenue Code of 1986 to treat certain income and gains relating to fuels as qualifying income for publicly traded partnerships, which, in effect means that businessmen wishing to establish ethanol pipelines domestically will be granted the same tax breaks as those who now own and operate pipelines that transport petroleum products.

The bill, entitled, Biofuels Pipeline Act of 2008 will hopefully provide another step in derailing oil speculation and behooving car companies to produce E85 vehicles by providing the alternative fuel in more places.

Donnelly: Only when we work together and take an “all-in” approach that utilizes America’s resources, labor, and ingenuity will we end our dependence on foreign oil, reduce energy prices, and make our country more secure.

Supporting Evidence: Donnelly actively works for greener legislation (www.donnellyforuscongress.com)
Side: Joe Donnelly
1 point

Donnelly endorses the SAVE Act, a rather conservative piece of legislation headed by Brian Bilbray (R-California) aimed at cracking down illegal immigration by keeping track of immigrants who pass through the criminal justice system via databases kept by Homeland Security.

The Act also stipulates record keeping and logging of all companies that have employed illegal immigrants and been indicted. Though Donnelly agrees that the "system[of immigration] is broken", he is mostly interested in the Act's stipulation for 8,000 patrolmen, E-verification for employers with past offenses and providing more funding to increase the level of border patrol technology. This proves that in order to get things done, Donnelly is willing to employ bipartisanship to reach a house consensus and fix America's immigration problems.

Donnelly: “Illegal immigration has become nothing short of a crisis in this country. The SAVE Act offers an immigration policy that strengthens our borders and enforces our employment laws. I will work with my colleagues on both sides of the aisle to get the bill to the floor.”

Supporting Evidence: Donnelly endorses SAVE Act (donnellywatch.wordpress.com)
Side: Joe Donnelly
3 points

Donnelly is an Obama supporter who has voted against withdrawing our troops from Iraq in 90 days and in favor of the FISA amendments. This is sure to put him at odds with his own party and can easily be used by Puckett to show that the Democrats don't really want to end the Bush administration's policies. As seen in many of his recent blogs, one of Puckett's strongest points of criticism for both Donnelly and Obama appears to have been their record of being against offshore drilling.

Side:
Luke Puckett (R)
Naje(432) Disputed
2 points

It is true that Donnelly supports Obama's energy plan and the rejection from Hoosiers democrats is perfectly legitimate, but given the Republican uproar regarding a lack in energy policy consensus before the summer recess, could it be that Obama and Donnelly are attempting to find some stable ground for a Congressional compromise?

Having such divisive tendencies regarding energy policy is what has cost congress precious time last session. Perhaps Donnelly is looking for a way to quicken energy stability and some principles must be knocked down in order to win a house majority on a bipartisan new energy bill?

Supporting Evidence: energy compromise (blogs.courant.com)
Side: Joe Donnelly
2 points

Luke Puckett is a refreshing change! He understands what Hoosiers need and has smart, fresh ideas to make needed changes and provide leadership for the district. He isn't afraid to rock the boat in Washington to fight for Hoosiers. I am especially impressed with his leadership and drive in regards to oil drilling in ANWR. This is a perfect illustration of his leadership - Mr. Puckett sees a problem, finds a solution, and does something about it. Unlike many politicians these days, he will actually take steps towards common-sense solutions rather than just talking about it.

Side: Luke Puckett
2 points

Congressman Donnelly has joined the majority of his Democratic colleagues by supporting the first and second versions of the Wall Street bailout bill. This ballot entry, like many others, limits voters to just two candidates, so Puckett will probably have to give some strong proof using his past record that he would fight this and any other wasteful spending.

Side:
Luke Puckett (R)