CreateDebate


Debate Info

8
4
Yes No
Debate Score:12
Arguments:12
Total Votes:12
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Yes (6)
 
 No (4)

Debate Creator

Srom(12206) pic



Are humans more vicious than animals?

Yes

Side Score: 8
VS.

No

Side Score: 4
2 points

Animals only kill or hurt for instinctual reasons: they're hungry or they fear for their own well-being or the well being of their offspring.

Humans can be absolutely vicious. We have inhumanely tortured and killed animals for their furs and tusks. Powerful individuals use the poor to their advantage to make even more money. We are the only species that created slavery of our own species. There are stories all the time of people killing for fun or boredom and dictators who kill their own people simply for not agreeing with them.

Animals rely on instinct. Humans can be disgusting.

Side: Yes
1 point

Just disputing two things:

Firstly, several species of ants are known to make slaves of members of other colonies- same species or otherwise.

Secondly, Animals do not 'rely on instinct' exclusively, which is what I'm pretty sure you're going for here. Only the simplest of creatures act purely out of instinct. The general populace seems to have this idea in their collective heads that intelligence/sentience/sapience is binary- either you have it, or you don't. This is completely unsupported by any experimental evidence. Evidence in fact strongly suggests intelligence to be a continuum, with humans tending towards the upper end.

Moreover, humans are nowhere close to being 'free' from instinct. Instinct affects all of us, and our actual ability to override our own instincts is highly overstated.

Side: No
1 point

They can be. If you're talking instinctively then I would say yes, simply because look how far we've come.

Side: Yes
1 point

Most animals hunt and kill through instinct or survival and as is widely believed true, have bigger brains with higher thought processes, yet we are the only animals that to my knowledge will hunt an animal to extinction, or knowingly destroy the planet on which we live, or invent "better", more imaginative ways of killing each other en mass at a single stroke, or hate another human just for their religious beliefs, sexuality or colour.

I'd say that makes us most vicious.

Side: Yes

Humans? Smarter than animals? Do you have any proof? ;)

Side: Yes
TheAshman(2299) Clarified
1 point

I have no proof, that's why I went with "widely believed to be true" rather than a bold statement of fact, i've certainly seen little to prove that they are

Side: Yes
1 point

we are the only animals that to my knowledge will hunt an animal to extinction

There are no snakes on the Hawaiian islands because the mongoose hunted them to extinction. When animals are put in a position of advantage, such as an invasive species with no natural predator, they will often kill off the organisms on which they live.

or knowingly destroy the planet on which we live

Algae create a massive dead zone in the gulf of mexico. Over-populated deer can destroy environments on which they thrive. Balance is only returned after years of starvation, or growing populations of predators thin out the heard and allow for the ecosystem to recover.

or invent "better", more imaginative ways of killing each other

Apes will beat each other with sticks. That's innovative. It may not be en mass, but if they were smarter it would be.

or hate another human just for their religious beliefs, sexuality or colour.

The apes that other apes choose to hit with sticks or rip their balls off are usually from a near by group that is viewed as a threat. That sounds like modern sociology to me.

Side: No
MKIced(2511) Clarified
1 point

"or knowingly destroy the planet on which we live

Algae create a massive dead zone in the gulf of mexico. Over-populated deer can destroy environments on which they thrive. Balance is only returned after years of starvation, or growing populations of predators thin out the heard and allow for the ecosystem to recover."

I'd like to point out that the OP said knowingly. I'm fairly certain the algae and deer don't hold meetings to say "Hey guys, we need to stop expanding because we're kinda overtaking the environment here."

Side: Yes

Yes

Side: Yes

Yes, all those mass killings and terrorists attacks..............................

Side: Yes

Looking at the majority...humans are less vicious .

Side: No

Humans are the only animals that care about the pain and suffering of their food.

Side: No