CreateDebate


Debate Info

8
8
Yes, Totally Contradictory No, God is Consistent
Debate Score:16
Arguments:12
Total Votes:17
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Yes, Totally Contradictory (5)
 
 No, God is Consistent (6)

Debate Creator

smilinbobs(590) pic



Is God too Contradictory to Exist

If we are to use "God's Word" the Bible or the Torah, God is too contradictory to even exist. One example is that we are told that God knows the future yet he screws up creation, knowing that he is screwing it up. 
Genesis 6:And it repented the Lord that he had made man on the earth, and it grieved him at his heart.

And the Lord said, I will destroy man whom I have created from the face of the earth; both man, and beast, and the creeping thing, and the fowls of the air; for it repenteth me that I have made them. 

Now with that said: how did that turn out?? Well I guess you'll have to read the Book but I will say this, it was not the last screw up for a guy who knows everything and can CREATE ANYTHING THE WAY THAT HE WANTS IT !!

Yes, Totally Contradictory

Side Score: 8
VS.

No, God is Consistent

Side Score: 8

Gods / religions exist only as long as there are people who believe in them.

Side: Yes, Totally Contradictory
krustyturtle(12) Disputed
1 point

NO .

Side: No, God is Consistent
HighFalutin(3402) Clarified
2 points

Greek mythology, who still believes in it? No one. Case closed, I've made my point.

Side: Yes, Totally Contradictory
2 points

The Christian God is contradictory, but that just means they didn't describe Him correctly. It is still possible for a God to exist as long as it isn't contradictory like the Biblical God.

Side: No, God is Consistent
TheCapConKid(293) Clarified
1 point

Unless it is like the Muslim holy book where if there is a contradiction, the one that was written last was/is the relevant one.

Side: Yes, Totally Contradictory
1 point

God punishes man because men with no morals and that want nothing to do with them try to explain him away by trying to contradict if men like this exist they are a threat to anyone who has them it must be OK to steal,kill and destroy because atheist say there is no God meaning no morals atheist are the reason behind death and destruction in the earth today God destroyed the earth because such men began to fill it if you took clay and made little men out of it and those men said you don't exist and that they came from food colouring to excuse their bad morals. men like this seek only the good of themselves and their own will telling others that there is no god so sin ran rampant in the earth man was given simple free will, the will to do good and evil God told him not to do evil but due to his sinful passions and lust and God saw 8 who wanted to b good because they cared for each other and were not selfish and saw the good for nothings and saved the 8 worthy ones God gave you a choice to do good with a warning of what followed doing the contrary say he doesn’t exists just to be evil and in hell atheist will lift there eyes and say "WE SCREWED UP!!!! That is my take on it Thank-you.

1sec ago Side: Yes, Totally Contradictory

Side: No, God is Consistent
1 point

God punishes man because men with no morals and that want nothing to do with them try to explain him away by trying to contradict if men like this exist they are a threat to anyone who has them it must be OK to steal,kill and destroy because atheist say there is no God meaning no morals atheist are the reason behind death and destruction in the earth today God destroyed the earth because such men began to fill it if you took clay and made little men out of it and those men said you don't exist and that they came from food colouring to excuse their bad morals. men like this seek only the good of themselves and their own will telling others that there is no god so sin ran rampant in the earth man was given simple free will, the will to do good and evil God told him not to do evil but due to his sinful passions and lust and God saw 8 who wanted to b good because they cared for each other and were not selfish and saw the good for nothings and saved the 8 worthy ones God gave you a choice to do good with a warning of what followed doing the contrary say he doesn’t exists just to be evil and in hell atheist will lift there eyes and say "WE SCREWED UP!!!! That is my take on it Thank-you.

1sec ago Side: Yes, Totally Contradictory

Side: No, God is Consistent
Cartman(18192) Disputed
1 point

First, periods ... learn to use them.

God punishes man because men with no morals and that want nothing to do with them try to explain him away by trying to contradict if men like this exist they are a threat to anyone who has them it must be OK to steal,kill and destroy because atheist say there is no God meaning no morals atheist are the reason behind death and destruction in the earth today God destroyed the earth because such men began to fill it if you took clay and made little men out of it and those men said you don't exist and that they came from food colouring to excuse their bad morals.

Uh, not according to Christianity. God punishes because of Adam and Eve who were definitely not Atheists.

men like this seek only the good of themselves and their own will telling others that there is no god so sin ran rampant in the earth man was given simple free will

So? The Christian says there is a god, so you can sin rampantly with your free will and just ask for forgiveness. How is that better?

Side: Yes, Totally Contradictory
2 points

No, but the Bible is contradictory. Therefore, the Bible in its entirety cannot be believed to describe God.

Side: No, God is Consistent
1 point

We are finite beings and god is infinite therefore his ways are different so we can not understand him or what he is.

Side: No, God is Consistent