CreateDebate


Debate Info

0
8
Oh God Yes! Hell no!
Debate Score:8
Arguments:6
Total Votes:8
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Hell no! (6)

Debate Creator

Hellno(17753) pic



Did Steve Martin Really Need to Apologize for "Offensive" Tweet?

(CNN) -- In days of yore, comedian Steve Martin said he used to try out jokes in clubs and adjust them based on an audience's feedback.

"Today, the process is faster. It's your brain, a button, then millions of reactions," he said on his website.

Martin was writing Monday to explain himself after sending a tweet that, by his own admission, was "unfortunate."

"To those who were offended, again, I offer a deep, sincere, and humble apology without reservation," he wrote. "But I feel I need to tell you the context and origin of the joke."

The storm started Friday when he invited people to ask him grammar questions on Twitter.

Someone wrote, "Is this how you spell lasonia?" to which Martin replied: "It depends. Are you in an African-American neighborhood or at an Italian restaurant."

"I knew of the name Lasonia. I did not make it up, nor do I find it funny. So to me the answer was either Lasonia (with a capital), or Lasagna, depending on what you meant. That they sounded alike in this rare and particular context struck me as funny. That was the joke," he wrote on his website.

"When the tweet went out, I saw some negative comments and immediately deleted the tweet and apologized. I gathered the perception was that I was making fun of African American names."

The story didn't stop there.

Martin said his tweet was picked up and quoted, inaccurately, by various outlets, including Salon.

"It depends. Are you in an African-American restaurant or at an Italian restaurant," Salon said Martin wrote, suggesting he meant to imply that African-American restaurants can't spell "lasagna."

The inaccurate version spread, and Martin said he felt he "couldn't get out of hell."

"Comedy is treacherous," he wrote. "But it's my job to know."

 

http://www.cnn.com/2013/12/23/showbiz/steve-martin-tweet/

Oh God Yes!

Side Score: 0
VS.

Hell no!

Side Score: 8
No arguments found. Add one!
3 points

I suppose if you interpreted the joke as blacks can't spell... yeah, that's a little offensive but if you interpreted it as blacks have stupid names... what the fuck? Who cares? They do use a lot of stoooopid names.

Side: Hell no!

So true, they have a lot of Arabic and French names. I did not say this by the way. I don't wanna get my ass kicked by politicrites.

Side: Hell no!

Oh geez, I have said worse. Leave him be, politicrites! Not you Hellno, the people having shit fits.

Side: Hell no!
1 point

If it's true he had already apologized for his actual tweet then he is not longer at fault. What salon did was reinvigorate an issue that was already dead, and made assumptions most likely out of his or her own insecurities.

Yes Steve martin should have apologized for the initial tweet, just to mind his public reputation, but now Salon is the only one who needs to apologize and it need to be to Steve.

Side: Hell no!
1 point

People need to chill the fuck out! Nobody would have been offended if it was Chris Rock who tweeted that.

Side: Hell no!
1 point

He didn't need to but he did the joke wasn't particularly offensive in the first place but after getting criticism he thought "I've upset people" did what he thought was right and apologised job done, he's now been misquoted Salon need to sort their shit out and apologise to him

Side: Hell no!