CreateDebate


Debate Info

12
10
Its is a genuine religeon Its a money making hoax!
Debate Score:22
Arguments:22
Total Votes:22
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Its is a genuine religeon (7)
 
 Its a money making hoax! (6)

Debate Creator

Tuxgirl(45) pic



Is Scientology a real religeon? Or is it a fake money making gimmick?

Scientology has been debated for many years. Its followers consider it a viable religion, however its critics consider it a money making cult.

 

What side are you on?

Its is a genuine religeon

Side Score: 12
VS.

Its a money making hoax!

Side Score: 10
5 points

All religions are fake, there's an argument to be made the vast majority are money making gimmicks.

Scientology is no more outlandish than any of the more widespread religions.

Side: Its is a genuine religeon
1 point

It is a genuine religion because Tom Cruise and John Travolta say so.

Side: Its is a genuine religeon

I am tempted to say "what's the difference"

It would appear that all religions have the same purpose in mind. Follow the leader and you go to heaven. As for being a money making cult, I'm sure Christianity, Catholicism, and Judaism to name a few started out with few people and in need of money to get launched, but look at them now.

Side: Its is a genuine religeon
1 point

It's both. I'm sure there are plenty of people who sincerely believe in, both as a follower and as an authority figure in Scientology, which makes it genuine. Yet at the same time, I'm sure there are plenty just milking people for their money.

Side: Its is a genuine religeon
3 points

All religions are fake money making gimmick .

Side: Its a money making hoax!
iamdavidh(4856) Clarified
1 point

To be fair, some aspects of some religions do have altruistic intentions, though I'd argue all are ultimately more harmful than good.

Still though, what about this religion specifically makes it not a "religion"?

Side: Its is a genuine religeon
Banana_Slug(845) Clarified
1 point

Actually it's a religion in all meanings. Yes it was started by scifi writer but look at the other.

Judaism - invented by guy who heard voices in his head telling him to cut his dick off and kill his son. Who also had often dialog with bush.

Christianity - fully established about year 300 fom mixture of different stories which lead to story about tricks doing magic homeless carpenter zombie...

Islam Invented by warlord and mass murdering pedophile as recruiting tool...

-so if you look at Scientology it doesn't look so bad. :D

Side: Its is a genuine religeon
3 points

It was created by a science-fiction writer.

Side: Its a money making hoax!
iamdavidh(4856) Clarified
2 points

So was the bible, qur'an, torah, tripitakas, bhagavad gita, etc

Are you arguing there is no such thing as religion then? If so okay. If not I think you are holding one religion to a different standard than others.

Side: Its is a genuine religeon
Elvira(3446) Clarified
1 point

We don't know if they were founded by a science fiction writer, though.

Side: Its is a genuine religeon
1 point

The reason it is a hoax is because the people at the top of their pyramid do not actually believe what they are saying. Hubbard himself violated many Scientologist principles such as drug use.

Side: Its a money making hoax!
iamdavidh(4856) Disputed
2 points

Leaders of the catholic church violate their religion by raping small boys.

So catholicism then is not a religion?

Side: Its is a genuine religeon
1 point

It is not recognised as a religion under English law. The court have found it to be a cult.

Side: Its a money making hoax!
1 point

all religions are. especially scientoloy, mormom and Jehovah's Witnesses.

Side: Its a money making hoax!

In my opinion, Scientology is out to make money and to cause mental perdition to their members.

Side: Its a money making hoax!