CreateDebate


Debate Info

8
3
It is wrong. It is not wrong.
Debate Score:11
Arguments:11
Total Votes:11
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 It is wrong. (8)
 
 It is not wrong. (3)

Debate Creator

haynes11(10) pic



Is it wrong to kill someone else's family if they killed yours?

Is it wrong to kill someone else's family if they killed yours? Personally for me I feel that this can't be put into subjects of right and wrong, but I'm curious of your opinions! Shoot away! :)

It is wrong.

Side Score: 8
VS.

It is not wrong.

Side Score: 3
1 point

Hard to say but I'd say it's not good, since revenge will get you no where.

Side: It is wrong.
1 point

I yhink it's wrong to kill someone else's family even if they killed yours because blood never solves the problem. Revenge kills man in us, comparing us to murders. Also killer's family members are innocent and it's cruel to kill they because of something that does not concern them.

Side: It is wrong.
1 point

i think it's wrong to kill someone else's family if they killed yours, because first of all we are not judges and we cannot deprive someone's lives. the life is long and everything can happen with you and of course life as a boomerang! even more the God sees everything.

Side: It is wrong.
1 point

it is wrong . according our constitution we must not kill people despite the fact that we hate this man . if we kill someone we will be murderer like them .

Side: It is wrong.
1 point

It is wrong morally first off. "Thou shall not kill" if you are not a Christian then lets look at from an angle of just being a good person. death is permanent therefore stopping anothers life or familys life based on revenge is still MURDER.

Side: It is wrong.
1 point

If you are interested in family debates, you can try debating this:

Supporting Evidence: Weak mother (www.createdebate.com)
Side: It is wrong.
1 point

I think it is wrong if someone killed my family I wouldn't get mad and get revenge but I would just continue to live life but it would be hard on me since I would miss my parents.

Side: It is wrong.

The law should handle the murderers. It would be wrong for the person whose family was killed to do the same.

Side: It is wrong.

The description pretty much nails it; there is no right or wrong, only what you perceive. Speaking Western socially though, I think it would be a 50/50 on whether it is right or wrong. So again, uncertain.

Honestly though, if someone killed my family, I wouldn't kill their's provided they didn't do anything, I'd just kill the guy himself.

Side: It is not wrong.
1 point

I am amazed when in such as cases people say that's wrong and it would be compared with themselves (murderers). Or when you say like we are not judges - they recognized themselves as judges first, when they decided to kill our native! Personally for me, this means war and I will start honest vendetta. Maybe, somebody won't understand me, but if (touch wood) my relative will be killed by anyone, nobody will be able to save him, really. Why do we have to tolerate those who stoped the life of our family's member?

Side: It is not wrong.
1 point

Not if its capital punishment. The government has every right to take someones life especially if they are proven guilty in the court of law.

Side: It is not wrong.